Did He Die? / Did He Died? (2005)Researching

added Jul 06, 2009 at 10:39AM UTC

part of a series on Trolling

This submission is currently being researched & evaluated!
You can help confirm this entry by contributing facts, media, and other evidence of notability and mutation.

About

“Did he die?” is a textual meme generally found in Youtube comments posted by trolls. Quite often, it is posted as a response to a fail video, particularly those on Failblog, but in some cases it is sometimes posted in comments on videos where there is no reason to even question if a person might have died.

Other variations on the phrase include, “did he died” or “did x died” where X is the subject of the video.

There is even a site based on these comments.

http://didhedie.com/

In December of 2008, one Urban Dictionary definition was created for “Did he died?” This definition has been voted up over 500 times.

A troll’s response to any video where a person is injured
Person 1: OMG he hit his nuts on the rail
Troll: Did He died?
Person 1: stfu you retard

In May and June of 2009, a few Urban Dictionary definitions were created for “did he die.” The highest voted has around 170 up-votes.

what people say on a failblog video on youtube

just look at one of the vids right now and read the comments you’ll know what i mean.
*guy trips and gets right up

person 1: did he die?
person 2: die he did?
person 3: did he dieded?
person 4: he clearly died
person 5: dead
person 6: FIRST!lol
person 7: WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON??!!?!?!?
person 8: did he death?
person 9 reply to 8: grammar fail
person 10: ok this is getting old

Trends

A Google Insights search for the phrase “did he die” is too general to return solid results because it picks up on the common phrase outside of the meme, along with phrases such as “how did he die” and “why did he die?”

But the phrase “did he died” shows that people have been searching for the grammatically incorrect version of the phrase since at least the beginning of 2005, even before the launch of Youtube.

Meta videos

Because of the proliferation of the “did he die” commenting meme, there have been videos made as commentary on the meme. Some come across as self-aware satires on the meme, while others serve as prime examples of exactly what’s so humorous about the meme: those who become aggravated and feed the trolls. These videos are not merely a part of the meme, but function as a metameme, examining the meme itself.

Add Photo

Login or Sign Up to add photos.

21 Comments

Captain Blubber
Jul 06, 2009 at 12:17PM UTC , Captain Blubber wrote:

I can’t find any photo versions of this.

I won’t deadpool until other people leave their opinions.

Mr.Meme
Jul 06, 2009 at 07:25PM UTC , Mr.Meme wrote:

I have the full backstory to this as given to me by a youtube user: Since YouTube exists, there have always been comments by persons we call “Gutmenschen” in German: Whenever someone would slip on a banana peel or something they would seriously go like “OMG HE COULD HAVE DIED HOW CAN YOU LAUGH AT THAT YOU HORRIBLE MONSTER!” Some weeks ago, people started mocking that annoying attitude by asking “Did he die?” in any context, and it spread quickly. It’s hilarious when you have experienced the background for ages…

AFAIK, it started on YouTube and not 4chan.

Andrew W
Jul 07, 2009 at 06:04AM UTC , Andrew W wrote:

False meme is a lie.

BrucePwnsyourface
Jul 07, 2009 at 06:20AM UTC , BrucePwnsyourface wrote:

honestly i don’t think this is a meme although i have seen it around but i think it mostly to the fact all the celebrity dieing in last week

Max nunyobisnis
Jul 07, 2009 at 07:13AM UTC , Max nunyobisnis wrote:

I will say the same thing I said in the thread in the forum about this same phrase:

This isn’t a meme. It can, however, be considered Copypasta.

Jamie Dubs
Jul 07, 2009 at 02:30PM UTC , Jamie Dubs wrote:

Copypasta-esque stuff should go in the forthcoming dictionary

triFeral
Jul 10, 2009 at 03:34PM UTC , triFeral wrote:

It’s annoying spam on youtube.
I wouldn’t call this a meme.

Chris Menning
Jul 11, 2009 at 04:11AM UTC , Chris Menning wrote:

I can’t wait to have the dictionary section. We get so much stuff that needs to go in a dictionary section.

WO.ot
Jul 11, 2009 at 09:38PM UTC , WO.ot wrote:

More often “did he died”

Richie McNuggets
Jul 13, 2009 at 11:03PM UTC , Richie McNuggets wrote:

oh! oh!
ive seen this so much on youtube!
i love this meme, totally is confirmable, needs better pic tho.

memes need to mutate and this is definately mutating, it started out with the simple “did he die?” which was the legit question then it became “did he died?”
then obvious troll became obvious and “did he deathed?” became popular.
its sooo funny reading the youtube comments and seeing ppl be like WTFFF at people asking if ppl died in a video about someone dropping a birthday cake

Nintendo_Freestyle
Jul 18, 2009 at 05:21AM UTC , Nintendo_Freestyle wrote:

The meme originated from Break.com. I know since I witnessed its popularity increase from Break to just about everywhere else. Feel free to go check ancient Break videos with pages of “did he died” and every single variation thereof. They’re still doing it now probably without any knowledge of their influence to the internet. Also “FAKE” was another meme gaining steam among Break users but didnt gain popularity in the rest of the internet. You post “FAKE” on any video thats clearly not just to infuriate others, “I can see the strings FAKE”.

Lagg0r
Jul 29, 2009 at 08:07PM UTC , Lagg0r wrote:

this could also be from the 1999 movie “Boondock Saints” when Rocco accidentaly shoots a cat he asks “is it dead?”

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1m-G9vrgPLk

stickmeister
Aug 08, 2009 at 12:57AM UTC , stickmeister wrote:

This is a meme. If you look at every Keyboard Cat video, several “did he die?” comments are found.

If I were you, I’d provide examples of the videos with the comments, and for images I suggest taking screencaps of comments.

Rofle Coptere
Aug 18, 2009 at 06:59PM UTC , Rofle Coptere wrote:

It’s common around youtube, but it might die out.

zomg!!
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:55PM UTC , zomg!! wrote:

I totaly hate it when they say “Did he die?” its really annoying

Keyboard Cat
Sep 29, 2009 at 04:46PM UTC , Keyboard Cat wrote:

Jack Mannik
Oct 23, 2009 at 09:04PM UTC , Jack Mannik wrote:

Keyboard cat FTW!

BoctorRodotnik
Feb 02, 2010 at 06:43PM UTC , BoctorRodotnik wrote:

Actually, this IS a meme. It fits the requirements for a meme, such as imitation and mutation. It usually goes in the form of “Did X die?” for example “Did the lizard die” ,“Did the robot die”, “did the house die”, or “did the sky die”. Also on several occasions there is the phrase “Did he live?”
So yes, it has both imitation and mutation and is a meme.

Kicker13
Feb 15, 2010 at 02:17AM UTC , Kicker13 wrote:

This is definitely gaining momentum and mutating.

Kicker13
Feb 15, 2010 at 03:28AM UTC , Kicker13 wrote:

Chris Menning
Mar 16, 2010 at 06:45PM UTC , Chris Menning wrote:

Revived from deadpool.

Login or Sign Up to participate!