Edit: Specific Details Please.
Forums / Fun! / Just For Fun
320,842 total conversations in 9,947 threads
The Great Debate.
Last posted
Jan 19, 2011 at 01:31AM EST.
Added
Jan 17, 2011 at 09:50PM EST
28 posts
from
17 users
Gandalf came back to life Dumbledore didn't, so yeah.
Gandalf can survive a fall.
hmm this is a close one I'm a fanboy of both so every fight I try to plan out ends with a stalemate…
While Dumbledore is pretty badass, I can't quite see him standing down a Balrog.
Dumbledore didn't have to be alive to kick Voldermort's ass by playing everyone like a pawn.
Trick Lobo wrote:
Dumbledore didn't have to be alive to kick Voldermort's ass by playing everyone like a pawn.
uh yeah but If you die you pretty much loose the fight…
Omomon
Deactivated
both can use magic very well
both are very experienced in fighting, with Gandalf slightly more advanced.
Dumbledore is a gay android tho…
Sweatie Killer
Deactivated
I heard there are gonna be new books in Harry Potter, and Dumbledore magically revives himself.
How about this guy from Shrek?
Omomon
Deactivated
^
no, he was awful. that movie was awful.
Omomon wrote:
^
no, he was awful. that movie was awful.
We all know. No need in pointing that out.
Gandalf's staff is bigger then Dumbleores.
So Gandalf.
Hmm..tough choice. Both are awesome, but I'd say Gandalf, for his wit. But dumbledore's plan was pretty epic in the books.
Piarte King wrote:
uh yeah but If you die you pretty much loose the fight…
>> Implying that death equals losing even if your plan kicks major ass and the death was only a minor snag in the plan.
Also, book Dumbledore > movie Dumbledore
Stoffe wrote:
Gandalf's staff is bigger then Dumbleores.
So Gandalf.
It's not the size of the staff, but how you use it; and as we've all certainly heard by now, Dumbledore really knows his way around a staff, if you know what I mean…
RainbowWizard wrote:
Vivi Wins the end.
Defense rests.
SexyThang
Deactivated
I nominate Leonard…
SexyThang
Deactivated
So much better than Dumb Bull Door…
Captain Badass
Deactivated
Obviously they're the same person. Every time Gandalf left in LotR, he had to go back to his job at Hogwarts.
Stoffe wrote:
Gandalf's staff is bigger then Dumbleores.
So Gandalf.
Sex joke goes here
Admiral Crunch wrote:
Sex joke goes here
Beat you already. (That's what she said!)
Gandalf is an idiot who planned out his plan to go to Mordor really badly. For instance, why the hell didn't he just have his eagles dunk the ring into Mount Doom? (And other things)
Dumbledore is a decent character in a really overrated franchise that has really stale movies.
In the end, Gandalf is more like Yoda, because Yoda does just about the same dmub bullshit as Gandalf in his movies. Both series are also full of idiocy, while still being very respectable in their own right and also masterpieces.
Because Gandalf is an idiot in a badass move/book series, I vote Gandalf.
Mad props if that makes sense to you.
Sweatie Killer
Deactivated
Katie C. wrote:
Gandalf is an idiot who planned out his plan to go to Mordor really badly. For instance, why the hell didn't he just have his eagles dunk the ring into Mount Doom? (And other things)
Dumbledore is a decent character in a really overrated franchise that has really stale movies.
In the end, Gandalf is more like Yoda, because Yoda does just about the same dmub bullshit as Gandalf in his movies. Both series are also full of idiocy, while still being very respectable in their own right and also masterpieces.
Because Gandalf is an idiot in a badass move/book series, I vote Gandalf.
Mad props if that makes sense to you.
So basically..
And you would not like a movie based on that idea?
edit:Why do they got shitty intros on these now :(