About

Bonnie Blue Is A Man or the Bonnie Blue Trans Conspiracy Theory refers to a transvestigation conspiracy theory claiming that OnlyFans model and adult movie actress Bonnie Blue is secretly a transgender woman and was born as a biological male named Kyle Butler. The rumors about Bonnie Blue being trans started garnering attention online as early as March 2025 and became increasingly prevalent on sites like X / Twitter and TikTok over the following months. In June 2025, rumors that Blue used to be named Kyle Butler before transitioning at 13 years old went viral, along with side-by-side photos allegedly showing Butler next to Blue and a purported Wikipedia page detailing her transition. There is no solid evidence that these pieces of evidence are real or that Blue ever transitioned, with the side-by-side photo claiming to show pre-transition Blue actually being an edited photo of Blue.

Origin

On March 12th, 2025, Redditor u/Ldmoran made a comment under a post to the /r/women^[1] subreddit asking, "Thoughts on Bonnie blue?" writing, "I think she is a trans woman and maybe that’s the reason she has such unique approach to sex?" garnering around one upvote in three months.

One of the earliest known posts sharing the conspiracy theory that gained significant attention was posted by X^[2] user @AshtronautGirl on May 13th, writing, "Bonnie Blue is actually a trans woman. There’s going to be thousands of men trying to delete themselves once they realize this," garnering over 1,300 likes in a month. The user provides no evidence to support their claim.

Spread

The rumors that Bonnie Blue is a trans woman garnered increased attention in June 2025, after a side-by-side image claiming to show Blue pre-transition and a screenshot of a purported Wikipedia page for a man named Kyle Butler, alleged to be Bonnie Blue pre-transition, went viral online. The alleged Wikipedia page claims that Butler transitioned at 13 years old.

On June 12th, 2025, X^[3] user @Elizabe32413720 posted the side-by-side, writing, "PSYOP !!" garnering over 1.3 million views and 2,900 likes in a week. This is the earliest known user to share the images, although it is unclear if they are the first.

Later that day, X^[4] user @AuntyMemeonX posted a low-quality screenshot taken from an unknown source of the alleged Wikipedia page as a comment under the post, garnering over 120 likes in a week. Again, it is unclear if this is the original version of the post, but it is the earliest known example.

On June 13th, 2025, X^[5] user @NoelleTMD commented under @Elizabe32413720's post a photo of Bonnie Blue that appears to be the original version of the alleged Kyle Butler photo, writing, "Nice try… It's an edited image," garnering around 80 likes in a week.

The rumors continued to spread over the following days. On June 13th, TikToker^[6] @hjbnews posted a video spreading the theory that gained over 8,000 views in a week.

That same day, Facebook^[7] user Karim Jovian posted the side-by-side, garnering over 3,500 reactions. Also on June 13th, X^[8] user @pashedmotatos posted, "You guys, Bonnie blue is not trans. Like her vagene is all over the place, you can look at it," garnering over 320 likes in a week.

On June 14th, Instagram^[9] user the_real_regulators posted the side-by-side, writing, "If this is true, can you imagine how the dudes are gonna feel," garnering over 6,000 likes in six days.

That same day, X^[10] user @BrockRiddickIFB made a post consisting of the side-by-side and alleged Wikipedia screenshot, along with two other images "transvestigating" Blue's body and skull proportions, garnering over 3,400 likes in six days.

On June 17th, 2025, Pink News^[11] published an article refuting the rumors about Blue being trans.

On June 19th, YouTuber^[12] Young Don Reacts posted a video reacting to content spreading the transition rumors, garnering over 49,000 views in under 24 hours.

Various Examples

Search Interest

External References