Andy is gulty of: Being kind of a jerk over peoples who lived in his barn without authorisation. Eventually warmed up to them.

Bismuth is guilty of: Trying to kill Steven when he told her that maybe shattering everyone we don't like wasn't the way to go.

Eyeball is guilty of: Trying to kill Steven after he healed her cracked gem and offered to share his bubble to protect her.

Jasper is guilty of: Trying to kill everyone, tried to force Lapis to fuse again, abducted gem monsters, forced one to fuse with her and other very evil deeds.

But yeah, clearly, Andy is the devil here and shouldn't have been given a chance at all, am I right?

Bismuth: Immediately attacked him after he told her that using the breaking point was wrong… after spending the whole day hanging out as friends AND giving him a pep talk.
Jasper: Hasnt even had a CHANCE to talk to her because she refuses to listen after mistaking him for Rose
Ruby: Spent possibly hours in his presence, and after he saves her life… she tries to shank him