Top Comments

TheDwarvenGuy
TheDwarvenGuy

in reply to Elbough Le Zoreil

Large scale attempts at agricultural collectivization have historically been proven to fail, mainly because forcing farmers to work or die isn't good enough of an incentive to innovate, and combining the bureaucracy of government with the delicate balance of cultivation is never a good idea.

See: The Ukrainian Famine, Great Leap Forward, etc.

And if your response is going to be "But it wasn't real communism if it had a government", my response to that would be a simple question:

How would you intend to organize large scale trade/infrastructure to bring food from farms to cities without any form of organization such as government or free trade?

+4

+ Add a Comment

Comments (10)


Display Comments

Add a Comment


Howdy! You must login or signup first!