Neon Genesis Evangelion - she's great

um…

Hey, I'm only joking here. Well, half-joking anyway.
I actually would consider who is best girl based on what her personality and interactions with the MC are like.
If I ever take physical appearance into the equation, though, especially when most of the girls (and sometimes some of the boys) have personalities I like and interactions with the MC that I find reasonable, what I said in my first comment still stands.