Rob Henderson @robkhenderson Every 6 months my mind returns to this heatmap indicating that conservatives devote the majority of their empathy and care to family and friends and liberals devote most of their concern to plants, trees, and inert entities such as rocks. nature.com/articles/s4146... ervatives 12 0 Libera:edure. All participants completed a moral allocation task, in which part s allocated 100 "moral units" among the following 16 categories, picture easingly large concentric circles (see full depiction of task in Supplementa 4): all of your immediate family; all of your extended family; all of your cl ds; all friends including more distant friends; all acquaintances; all peopl have ever met; all people in your country; all people on your continent; eople on all continents; all mammals on all continents; all hibians, reptiles, mammals, fish, and birds; all animals on earth includin mecia and amoebae; all animals in the universe, including alien lifeforms g things in the universe including plants and trees; all natural things in 1 erse including inert entities such as rocks; all things in existence. Particip the following instructions: n this section, we would like to think about your capacity to help, to give o be charitable, to show empathy, and to be generous-in other words our capacity to behave morally. We can think about people having lifferent amounts of moral units-like currency-that they can spend or others and can allocate to different moral circles. Some people devote all o heir moral units to one circle whereas others try to divide up their mora inits amongst multiple circles. Again, by moral circle, we mean the circle o people or other entities in which you are concerned about right and wrong lone toward them. oral allocation by ideology, Study 3a. Source data are provided as a Source Dave also explained to participants that these categories were non-overlapp and 12 units for conservatives. Moral circle rings, from inner to outer, are d that giving to one category (e.g., extended family) would not include an nded family, (3) all of your closest friends, (4) all of your friends (including sive category (e.g., immediate family). Participants completed two iteration e ever met, (7) all people in your country, (8) all people on your continent, (task (order randomized). In one, they were asked to allocate moral units , mammals, fish, and birds, (12) all animals on earth including paramecia an should ideally divide them. In the other, they were asked to divide them as > all living things in the universe including plants and trees, (15) all natural tonally do so in their daily lives. These allowed us to assess differences bet al and ideal moral allocation, but no meaningful differences emerged. T existence 4:07 AM • May 7, 2023 529.6K Views

Share Pin Download More

moral circles moral circle rings conservatives liberals moral allocation moral distribution

Origin Entry: Moral Circles Heatmap

File type: jpg

Resolution: (1044px x 1050px)

File size: 740 KB

An Opinion Dismissed image macro based on the liberal Moral Circles heatmap.

A user uses the "Opinion Dismissed" meme based on the liberal Moral Circles heatmap against another user on X.

A user argues that liberal moral allocation is more destructive than islamophobia.

View All 20 Images

More:

The Procedure for the "Moral Circles" Study

A detailed description of the "Moral Circles" part the "Ideological differences in the expanse of the moral circle" study

Pin

Moral Circles Study With Additional Context

A extract from the "Ideological differences in the expanse of the moral circle" study which provides more context into the Moral Circles heatmap and its accuracy.

Pin

Moral Circles Heatmap: Conservatives vs. Liberals (With Annotation)

Heatmaps indicating highest moral allocation by ideology. Moral circle rings, from inner to outer, are described as follows: (1) all of your immediate family, (2) all of your extended family, (3) all of your closest friends, (4) all of your friends (including distant ones), (5) all of your acquaintances, (6) all people you have ever met, (7) all people in your country, (8) all people on your continent, (9) all people on all continents, (10) all mammals, (11) all amphibians, reptiles, mammals, fish, and birds, (12) all animals on earth including paramecia and amoebae, (13) all animals in the universe, including alien lifeforms, (14) all living things in the universe including plants and trees, (15) all natural things in the universe including inert entities such as rocks, (16) all things in existence.

Pin

Moral Circles Heatmap: Conservatives vs. Liberals

Heatmaps indicating highest moral allocation by ideology. Moral circle rings, from inner to outer, are described as follows: (1) all of your immediate family, (2) all of your extended family, (3) all of your closest friends, (4) all of your friends (including distant ones), (5) all of your acquaintances, (6) all people you have ever met, (7) all people in your country, (8) all people on your continent, (9) all people on all continents, (10) all mammals, (11) all amphibians, reptiles, mammals, fish, and birds, (12) all animals on earth including paramecia and amoebae, (13) all animals in the universe, including alien lifeforms, (14) all living things in the universe including plants and trees, (15) all natural things in the universe including inert entities such as rocks, (16) all things in existence.

Pin

+1

Moral Circles Heatmap - Every 6 months my mind returns to this heatmap indicating that conservatives devote the majority of their empathy and care to family and friends and l...

PROTIP: Press the ← and → keys to navigate the gallery, 'g' to view the gallery, or 'r' to view a random image.

Rob Henderson @robkhenderson Every 6 months my mind returns to this heatmap indicating that conservatives devote the majority of their empathy and care to family and friends and liberals devote most of their concern to plants, trees, and inert entities such as rocks. nature.com/articles/s4146... ervatives 12 0 Libera:edure. All participants completed a moral allocation task, in which part s allocated 100 "moral units" among the following 16 categories, picture easingly large concentric circles (see full depiction of task in Supplementa 4): all of your immediate family; all of your extended family; all of your cl ds; all friends including more distant friends; all acquaintances; all peopl have ever met; all people in your country; all people on your continent; eople on all continents; all mammals on all continents; all hibians, reptiles, mammals, fish, and birds; all animals on earth includin mecia and amoebae; all animals in the universe, including alien lifeforms g things in the universe including plants and trees; all natural things in 1 erse including inert entities such as rocks; all things in existence. Particip the following instructions: n this section, we would like to think about your capacity to help, to give o be charitable, to show empathy, and to be generous-in other words our capacity to behave morally. We can think about people having lifferent amounts of moral units-like currency-that they can spend or others and can allocate to different moral circles. Some people devote all o heir moral units to one circle whereas others try to divide up their mora inits amongst multiple circles. Again, by moral circle, we mean the circle o people or other entities in which you are concerned about right and wrong lone toward them. oral allocation by ideology, Study 3a. Source data are provided as a Source Dave also explained to participants that these categories were non-overlapp and 12 units for conservatives. Moral circle rings, from inner to outer, are d that giving to one category (e.g., extended family) would not include an nded family, (3) all of your closest friends, (4) all of your friends (including sive category (e.g., immediate family). Participants completed two iteration e ever met, (7) all people in your country, (8) all people on your continent, (task (order randomized). In one, they were asked to allocate moral units , mammals, fish, and birds, (12) all animals on earth including paramecia an should ideally divide them. In the other, they were asked to divide them as > all living things in the universe including plants and trees, (15) all natural tonally do so in their daily lives. These allowed us to assess differences bet al and ideal moral allocation, but no meaningful differences emerged. T existence 4:07 AM • May 7, 2023 529.6K Views

View Gallery Random Image

+ Add a Comment

Comments (0)

There are no comments currently available.

Display Comments

Image Details

367 views (22 from today)

Uploaded Jan 08, 2025 at 09:54AM EST

Origin Entry

Moral Circles Heatmap

Source

Tags

Claim Authorship Edit History

About the Uploader

Philipp

Memesplainer

Textile Embed

!https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/002/983/912/1d1.jpg!

Today's Top Image Galleries

Elon Musk Sieg Heil Salute at Donald Trump Inauguration image example.

Elon Musk Heil Salute

Elon Musk and X-Chan Efficiency Comic by SKS Cartoons.

X-Chan "Efficiency" Comic

My Little Pony characters

My Little Pony

Casual Mai Shiranui meme depicting the Street Fighter 6 character lounging in a chair.

Casual Mai Shiranui