O HAI! You must login or signup first!

Now Im not saying that Pke s alowed to have fws That would be absoludely rdiculous. She's always had Raws Those taws are actualy a lack of ompathy, a dtty demeanor, and chidsh tender as seers poty smar to wha ago, but those are her chiel fws Hor bad appearances are just those exaggersted to where 赠 panta to watch Alackofompathy doesn't mean that she doesn" know what ermot ons an--t means th she has dtcuty seeing what oter pones are teerg, which mostly manfests tselt in not sealzing that she's annoying others This aspect of hers has been used n A Friend in Deed and abused in Luna Ecipsed, F Van, and The Super Speedy Cder Squeery 6000 Do you know whatl saves her charactlerization in thait episode (for me at east)? She's clearly regnetful for causing someone else misery She just doesn't know exactly how to go about foong the problem In her other appearances, this lack of empathy almost seems malicious Even if Pinkes not out of character these appearances get way The Pinkie Problem and that problom has I stated jurst a paragraph So, I've been saying that been Pinkie's characerization A let of people seemm to bebeve hat Pinkie has been ine, the sano as she's always been, or harmless That's a perfectly vaid opnon (hat I dont》 sharo and there is a ce as "n character Spke from Spike at Your Service, Twilight in Feeling Pe Koon, Ranbow Dash n May the Best Pet Winl, everyhing Season 4 has had one consistant problom, way of looking at things whee you take every character's perlomar could do that-actually no I couldn't,since m a crtic, but hypothotically i I could, I woud have to assume that Piniie lacks any sense of empathy (The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 000 F Va is season four appearances) Regardess of whether or not that's a vald viowpoint, that's not a good charactet. I define a good character as someone you can relate to,someone you can ook up to, or somoone you want to be And Pinke does for should) ft into all three ol those categories at her best Alt her worst well maybe her latest appearance wasnt a Stuck in the Wringer, but she's well on her way and its not out of the realm of plausibility (we're kinda butalo to stamgede hrough shear annoyance She's aso been shown to have a very good we'se kinda in Toy Store of Doom tentory).Like I said, all t takes is thaf unapologesc wreckless abandon to cause a potom mstead of just make worse Sowore gong to try to Oklwould butteng more hn soek ng than perhaps whas teat y Maybe she does cior igure out what makes Pinkie tick. Doing so may prove futle, but not doing so may prove dangerous a complete idiot (Over a Barre) and has the mind of a child (most of her Now what's the dmerence between a dry demeanor and complete idiot? Someone 。 5mply dtz would be atio to (reatvety)functon n sooety Anonnandenzed Price wouldit do sonet ngthat could concevaby havo a positive o tome, ike say cause the memory(AFnendi, Deod) The final fBW lSchkhsh tendances-not exacty dong what a in coloring books, but she does know that she wouldnT leam about kiter plants inside of one Pincess Twight Spande) Yeah, thats prony much the m Seven Commandents of Witng Pe Ple, in Priue's What's most important to Pinkie? Her triends. Making them smile Goi words She may not succeed in this, but these should almost akeays be her idention Fluttershy's worst fears to the point where sho's crying spits in the face of that and what she eealy cares about. Im not just saying this because this is how l think Pinke should be wtws people saying ' did his because bla lhba" al aways know WH We've had plenty of evidence about this Remember what happened when Gida made Fluttershy cry in Griffon the Brush-Ofl, and how far out of her way she went to fx t Pirnk lack of empathy is not bad enough to not know what tears or a smle signity Do you know what really annoys me about F循waw? rsthe fact that Amy Keatrg Rogers practaby wnote the istruction book to weting Pinie and placed it in her episodes (the yrics ef the songs are wten by the wers by the way ng off the handle about And thait bings us to our inal point of the day explainng vs scuning Iget thes a lot in my dd what they did Fluthershy berated her tiends because Iron Wil f----- her up in the bead That explains what Flutershy dd, but it does not eouse Flutershy su ering some ond of consequence for that action would "excure a (depending on the consequences Fluteeshy did, but it does not According to Amy Keating Rogers, Pkie speaking without inking xplas trowing does no 'excuse" t, ke some sort of regret on Pie's part y the way. when Isay s, is puroly a story wt *For all my 0fo a rve wanted to dowas mako my trends want to smie tru case) And that is the atal aw here You know Pie crushed Rainbow under a pin n Pioe Pride Pnice geting jealous explans" but Pnie willing to Merally move out o town eouses that behavior Ths Exouse Vs Explaning is how I've been judging every "Thenes gotta be mone to me tman planning a party or two "They loved seoing me, the real PinkiaShow them the time of their ie ke theyve 愯doesn't meter now if you are sad or blocausechoenng up my honds is just what actruation so far by the way lke Babs Seed trom One Bad Apple, Raibow Dash n May ohe Best Pat W Twlignt in Ows Weld That Ends We Yes, all ofheir actions have been Explained but the episodes did not hom well enough for me Um Itink ve lost tack of what I was trying to say Oh yeah Piko has the potental to be a geat character, even a le model as long as you ken a leash on her ws Know hem inside and out and囟not trytoloppeevous moneresofdt, and you atheOn、and Amy Keating Rogers' work on"excuser Prkie's behavor rtho es esode and rot .expand"處on hiter Ple's Pere to do The corners of your mout turned up is aways Pnke's dream T give a smale Iget a smld hsso special to me

+5

The Pinkie Problem


Uploaded by Eris Feb 16, 2014 at 01:55AM EST

Share Pin Download More

Origin Entry: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic

File type: jpg

Resolution: (582px x 460px)

File size: 89.7 KB


HEY PUNK, THAT'S OUR TURF! HTTPS://WWW.DEVIANTART.COM/SATURDAYMORNINGPROJ
22 び
View All 220,474 Images

Load 16 Comments

More:

Top Comments

WhipperSnapper
Delete
Sensitive
WhipperSnapper

I think the problem for a Pinkie was that she kept doing it in the episode. The first time she did it, in which Rarity paper slap her and called her out on it, we could let it slide. But then she kept on doing that. Even when the others shown to disapprove it.

+7
Reply
rust1cw4r3
Delete
Sensitive
rust1cw4r3

in reply to xTSGx

Actually its a very on the nose and well articulated opinion piece on what is wrong with Pinkie Pie (or what has been wrong with her since season 3 began). I find myself agreeing with some parts while disagreeing with others, but have respect for how well the author shows his side of the story. Give it a read if you haven't already. Its ironic for me really, AKR is both simultaneously responsible for both the high (Pinkie Pride) and low (Pinkie's portrayal in Fili Vanilli) points of season 4 for me thus far.

+6
Reply

+ Add a Comment

Comments (16)


Display Comments

Add a Comment


+ Add an Image

Image Details

532 views (8 from today)

Uploaded Feb 16, 2014 at 01:55AM EST

Origin Entry

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic

Tags

pinkie pie, flanderization, themysteriousmrenter

Claim Authorship Edit History
Textile Embed