Notes:

1999: Ripped pants (Ripped Pants)
2000: Kuddly (Bossy Boots)
2001: Singer (Band Geeks)
2002: The Quickster (Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy V)
2003: Flight (The Sponge Who Could Fly)
2004: Goofy Goober (The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie)
2005: Krabby O Mondays (Selling Out)
2006: Hotel (Krusty Towers)
2007: Starving yet Crazy (To Save a Squirrel)
2008: Normal (Not Normal)
2009: Ghost (The Curse of Bikini Bottom)
2010: Enchanted Tiki (Enchanted Tiki Dreams)
2011: Golf (A Friendly Game)
2012: Tired (InSPONGEiac)
2013: Prison Security Guard (Jailbreak!)
2014: (It Came from Goo Lagoon)