IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT ANYONE ELSE HAS TO LISTEN TO YOUR B-------, PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT: THE RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH MEANS THE GOVERNMENT CANT ARREST YOU FOR WHAT YOU SAY. THE 1ST AMENDMENT DOESN'T SHIELD YOU FROM CRITICISM OR CONSEQUENCES. OR HOST YOU WHILE YOU SHARE IT. IF YOU'RE YELLED AT, BOYCOTTED, HAVE YOUR SHOW CANCELED, OR GET BANNED FROM AN INTERNET COMMUNITY, YOUR FREE SPEECH| A------, RIGHTS AREN'T BEING VIOLATED. IT'S JUST THAT THE PEOPLE LISTENING THINK YOU'RE AN AND THEY'RE SHOWING YOU THE DOOR. What Randall's trying to do here is put an end to people claiming that their First Amendment rights are being violated when in fact, they're not. And the comic does a good job at that. My problem with the comic is that it doesn't address the difference between the two kinds of intellectual cultures we've discussed-and as such, it serves as perfect justification for both the Idea Lab and the Echo Chamber. For me, the critical word in the comic is "a------." Both kinds of intellectual culture agree with the comic-what they disagree on is the definition of a------. Communities that define a------ as "someone who in arguments attacks people, not ideas," or "someone who expresses conviction on viewpoints where they don't actually know very much," or "someone who never admits when they're wrong" are Idea Labs. They eject from the club those who turn arguments into fights and hinder the community's ability to search for truth. On the other hand, communities that define a------ as "someone who disagrees with what the community believes," or "someone who holds views that we find offensive," or "someone who criticizes the community or defends our rival community" are Echo Chambers. By "showing the door" to anyone who doesn't say their baby is cute, they purge their community of dissent and ensure that things remain intellectually pure. The xkcd comic is a comic about intolerance-but the key question it leaves open is: intolerance of what? When you consider your own judgments and those within your communities, think about the criteria for intolerance. Ask yourself: How exactly is "a------" being defined?

Share Pin Download More

wait but why xkcd echo chamber idea lab rebuttal text

Origin Entry: xkcd

File type: png

Resolution: (729px x 1042px)

File size: 204 KB

OKAY, MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENTS, IT'S THE FIRST TUESDAY IN FEBRUARY. 1 THIS MEANS THAT BY LAW AND CUSTOM, WE MUST SPEND THE MORNING READING THROUGH THE WIKIPEDIA ARTICLE LIST OF COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS, 50 YOU CAN SPEND THE REST OF YOUR LIVES BEING A LITTLE LESS WRONG. 1 THE GUESTS AT EVERY PARTY YOU'LL EVER ATTEND THANK US IN ADVANCE. DR I WISH I LIVED IN THIS UNIVERSE.

ALL MODERN DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE Ang A PROJECT SOME RANDOM PERSON IN NEBRASKA HAS BEEN THANKLESSLY MAINTAINING SINCE 2003

MAN, I SUCK ATTHIS GAME. CAN YOU GIVE ME A FEW POINTERS? OX3A28213A Ox 6339392C, OX7363682E. I HATE YOU.

View All 144 Images

Load 4 Comments

More:

+4

xkcd - Questioning Xkcd comic

PROTIP: Press the ← and → keys to navigate the gallery, 'g' to view the gallery, or 'r' to view a random image.

IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT ANYONE ELSE HAS TO LISTEN TO YOUR B-------, PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT: THE RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH MEANS THE GOVERNMENT CANT ARREST YOU FOR WHAT YOU SAY. THE 1ST AMENDMENT DOESN'T SHIELD YOU FROM CRITICISM OR CONSEQUENCES. OR HOST YOU WHILE YOU SHARE IT. IF YOU'RE YELLED AT, BOYCOTTED, HAVE YOUR SHOW CANCELED, OR GET BANNED FROM AN INTERNET COMMUNITY, YOUR FREE SPEECH| A------, RIGHTS AREN'T BEING VIOLATED. IT'S JUST THAT THE PEOPLE LISTENING THINK YOU'RE AN AND THEY'RE SHOWING YOU THE DOOR. What Randall's trying to do here is put an end to people claiming that their First Amendment rights are being violated when in fact, they're not. And the comic does a good job at that. My problem with the comic is that it doesn't address the difference between the two kinds of intellectual cultures we've discussed-and as such, it serves as perfect justification for both the Idea Lab and the Echo Chamber. For me, the critical word in the comic is "a------." Both kinds of intellectual culture agree with the comic-what they disagree on is the definition of a------. Communities that define a------ as "someone who in arguments attacks people, not ideas," or "someone who expresses conviction on viewpoints where they don't actually know very much," or "someone who never admits when they're wrong" are Idea Labs. They eject from the club those who turn arguments into fights and hinder the community's ability to search for truth. On the other hand, communities that define a------ as "someone who disagrees with what the community believes," or "someone who holds views that we find offensive," or "someone who criticizes the community or defends our rival community" are Echo Chambers. By "showing the door" to anyone who doesn't say their baby is cute, they purge their community of dissent and ensure that things remain intellectually pure. The xkcd comic is a comic about intolerance-but the key question it leaves open is: intolerance of what? When you consider your own judgments and those within your communities, think about the criteria for intolerance. Ask yourself: How exactly is "a------" being defined?

View Gallery Random Image

+ Add a Comment

Comments (4)

Display Comments

Image Details

1,307 views (6 from today)

Uploaded Sep 27, 2020 at 12:27AM EDT

Origin Entry

Source

xkcd, Wait But Why

Tags

Claim Authorship Edit History

About the Uploader

Evilthing

Treasurer & Elocutionist & Media Chauffeur

Textile Embed

!https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/001/901/139/fd6.png!

Today's Top Image Galleries

Queen Never Cry meme.

Queen Never Cry

Wifejak meme format depicting a female wojak character with red hair and a grey shirt.

Wifejak

The Social Contract

The Social Contract

A photo of Furries at a furry convention.

Furries / Furry