Forums / Media / Moving Images

18,587 total conversations in 827 threads

+ New Thread


Star Wars: (The Spoilering) Review Thread

Last posted Dec 29, 2015 at 01:44AM EST. Added Dec 21, 2015 at 12:56AM EST
8 posts from 8 users

This post has been hidden due to low karma.
Click here to show this post.

In the new movie they blow up a planet-sized Death Star and thus prove the director has 0 originality.

One of the storm troopers also defects in an epic twist that anyone could've easily thought of.

The new villains don't come close to Darth Vader because they never had a chance of surpassing that high quality of a villain. That said, the guy replacing Darth Vader is some emo bitch guy that doesn't have a particularly compelling story, personality, or design about him and his master is some alien thing that belongs in a marvel movie.

Han Solo gullibly dies to his emo son who is the new darth vader wannabe nobody gives a shit about.

Basically the entire movie constantly shoves the orb-shaped droid in your face like "ooooohhh look at this cute little toy I bet you wished you owned one it's so adorableee" to a point where it's obnoxious and ruins that first hint of originality they had.

Overall they ripped off a bunch of stuff from earlier movies and Luke is now a hermit like Yoda and in other news I stopped caring about the plot because it's just one rip-off after another but hey, the movie at least had nice graphics.

The nice graphics were par for the course for a typical star wars movie.

The new main female protagonist with force powers seems like a wimp and bored me. I don't find her particularly compelling beyond "oh look she's poor" and the male sidekick is the black defected storm trooper who can't do shit with the force and actually seems like a far better character I enjoyed. We can now at least say Lando isn't the only black guy in the universe now.

I had hopes that the soundtrack might be improved and innovated but it didn't sound all that different or interesting.

This movie might have been the weakest one in the franchise, I give it 2.5 stars out of 4 due to it's massive ripping of previous ideas from earlier movies and lack of hardcore innovation beyond some expected changes here and there.

On a side note I wish the bad guy had been Luke, thus fulfilling Yoda's prophecy that Luke would follow the dark path if he left his training early. Now Yoda's just the fool who doubted that one guy for no reason and instead we have this emo jackass wannabe of a character.

Only thing I'm disappointed with is no Wilhelm Scream. Why no Wilhelm Scream? It's meant to persist throughout the ages!

Overall, movie is fantastic, go see it.

Last edited Dec 21, 2015 at 02:20AM EST

ITT: "Star Wars The Force Awakens is bad because I didn't like it."

Your biased opinion =/= An actual review. Maybe if you gave a logical explanation on each point rather than a emotional tantrum of all the things you don't like then, maybe, it could have been a good review.

1,5/10, worthy of being a youtube comment.

Last edited Dec 21, 2015 at 02:26AM EST

Freakenstein wrote:

Only thing I'm disappointed with is no Wilhelm Scream. Why no Wilhelm Scream? It's meant to persist throughout the ages!

Overall, movie is fantastic, go see it.

except there was a wilhelm scream. It was faint, but it was there during the escape from the hangar scene.

I don't have a full review but I have some thoughts.

The opening scene is really good. It mixes grit with Star Wars action in a really engrossing way. Too bad the rest of the movie is incredibly tame compared to it.

Finn's performance was much better then I expected from the trailers. He acts pretty natural for the most part (minus the bit in the bar where he NEEDS TO RUN AWAY but instantly changes his mind when the weapon fires).

Ray (Rey?) on the other hand felt out of place. It's either her incredibly british accent in the middle of a desert, or her bizarre insistence on not taking the lightsaber.

The pilot guy from the beginning and Phazma were incredibly underused. Together they had only like 10 minutes of screentime. Surely they could have used then more instead of those scenes with Pri-General Leia. Also, how did the pilot guy survive the crash? That was never explained…

Han Solo is pretty fun in the movie and Chewbacca feels like he's actually contributing to the plot, more than in the original movies even.

Those tentacle things in Han's freighter looked lousy. They moved too fast so you could really tell they're CGI. (why does Finn say they're captured by the First Order when the freighter takes them in?)

I liked the new style cantina scene with the different music, and both sides of the war seeing BB8

Kylo Ren was a pretty neat character. He's a whiny little bitch like Anakin from the prequels, but he's the villain so he feels like he's right where he belongs.

Lord Snoke is a joke. He's a big hologram of a cgi fart monster. Please somebody replace him with an actual person in the sequel.

I liked the scene on Starkiller base that was obviously set up to look like a Nazi rally. It felt authentic enough to work.

Why did they get a cameo for Admiral Ackbar but not have any other rebel ships besides X Wings? Y Wings need some love.

Why does Starkiller Base blow up when they said hitting the oscillator would only disable it.

Lightsaber fight was okay. Not too overly coreographed, but the camera needs some work.

I think it felt very much like if an EU novel was put to film. It had the feel of one of the New Jedi Order series, almost.
It was like looking through a box of old photographs and toys "Hey, look! Han and Chewie!" "Awesome, The Millenium Falcon"

It's pretty much a big Introduction and it feels like it's just revving up for something bigger. But I think it was a very well done "introduction" to a new trilogy.

The new leads, I had low hopes for. But Rey's actress was great, even though I think her character was a bit bland. And Finn was actually really badass.

So yeah, I think it was pretty great. I give it an 8/10.

Kylo Ren is such a clever idea for a character. His introduction is a wonderful fake out. When we first see him, we think he's just "Darth Vader again." He's got the scary costume, the computerized voice, and the force powers. Then he takes off that helmet and…he's some guy. If you passed him in the street, you wouldn't give him a second glance. Pretty soon, it becomes obvious that he's basically a kid desperately trying to imitate Darth Vader, but he's struggling with pangs of conscious. This teasing of redemption made it more tragic when he goes past the tipping point into the Dark Side. In short: he's young Anakin done right. Think about it. In the relatively few scenes we had with Kylo Ren, we learn nearly everything we need to know about him, feel his struggle, and witness his turn. Effective brevity in storytelling. Compare that to watching Anakin bitch and moan his way through three films and the choice is obvious.

Overall, I liked The Force Awakens, though it's kind of hard for me to accept it as canon. As I've said before, I see no reason why the pre and post Disney universes can't exist as equally valid canons, but it just seems weird to me that we've been hearing about what happens after Jedi for decades, only for this new movie to come and say "Nope. This is how it really happened." Still, I had fun, even if parts of it came across as a bit fanfiction-y.

"This is Starkiller Base. It's like the Death Star, but way bigger and can blow up, like, three planets at once. Original space station! Do not steal!"

Skeletor-sm

This thread is closed to new posts.

Old threads normally auto-close after 30 days of inactivity.

Why don't you start a new thread instead?

Hi! You must login or signup first!