O HAI! You must login or signup first!

Thiago Abortion in certain tribes pre colonialism was actually pretty sacred and normal. But due to colonialism a lot of that was lost. As well as every place in the US is native land, not just what's considered a reservation. Lots of tribes wouldn't have the funds or the means to open a clinic as most don't even have access to clean water. It's also kind of ... weird to turn to natives to demand they open abortion clinics for non natives, on stolen native land, only caring when you yourself are in crisis. If tribes choose to open clinics for the public than that's great! But I think asking that of underprivileged people is a bit iffy. RvW getting overturned is absolutely evil. Edit; as well as what others have been saying, opening clinics could put the tribes in danger. More danger than they already are in day-to-day. Demanding native people open a clinic and put themself in violent harms way? Yeah no. Edit 2; changed some wording! 1 Reply Give Award Share Report 58 min. ago edited 29 min. ago Abortion in tribes pre colonialism was actually pretty sacred and normal... Please stop spreading falsehoods. Inducing miscarriages did happen and have always happened in every society, but they weren't "normal" and you'd be hard-pressed to find more than a handful of scattered examples of groups treating the intentional abortion of a female's life-giving power (which was how women were typically viewed in pre-colonial societies-as life-givers) as something "sacred." 1 The most common studies find: ...the circumstances that now provoke women to have abortions did not manifest themselves in the pre-colonial era; the cultural and economics situation of pre-colonial women was such that abortion would be useless and absurd; and reliable field work failed to disclose any significant incidence of pre-colonial abortion. Edit: As a member of the Yakama people, all these downvotes tell me is that you really don't actually care about Native voices or scholarly research and instead choose to embrace second- hand misperceptions that paint my people as mystical progressives whose ancient practices just happen to magically align with your worldview. 3 56 min. ago I have literally received information from multiple tribes on how abortions were pre colonialism from tribal members. I am not making something up, I am reiterating information directly from native people. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow Maybe normal wasn't the right word! But it wasn't socially ostracized or judged. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 2 52 min. ago There is a world of difference between the facts (indigenous women were not socially stigmatized on the rare occasions when they had to induce a miscarriage) and the statement that such practices were "normal and sacred." Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 0 43 min. ago I'm autistic and I often use the wrong words. That's my bad. I'll be trying to re find the source but I think they changed their username so it might take me a bit. 1 Save 1 Follow 41 min. ago Then you should edit your post to correct those wrong words. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow Blk.native on Instagram. 37 min. ago Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 34 min. ago She is a radical ideologue who does not speak for many Navajo or indigenous women. "Abortion is not a solution for Native women" - Navajo Times Tomorrow, hundreds of Native people from the United States and Canada will be joining hundreds of thousands of marchers in Washington, D.C., for the annual March for Life. We will be marching because life is sacred from the very moment of conception. As a Native American woman, I know this to be true at a fundamental level. It has taken centuries for our Native peoples to be afforded the human rights that all people deserve by their very nature. 1 31 min. ago Ok listen I've tried to be peaceful with you but I literally do not care and I am not arguing with you. Any individual person can have an opinion about something. It is, however, a fact that historically and culturally abortion was accepted and celebrated amongst certain tribes. If a Navajo woman chooses to betray other women this way, I literally do not care. Either listen to the facts or go home. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow Do not respond if you're going to try to argue with me. I have better things to be doing. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow I am a Yakama. 0 1 You and that activist are full of b-------. It has never been celebrated by our people or any other that I have spoken with. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 25 min. ago Ok congrats ur tribe is pro birth. What do u want a cookie? Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 0 26 min. ago 23 min. ago I'd rather have privileged white people actually listen to us rather than picking and choosing whatever version of the past makes them feel better about their own views. Our beliefs don't exist to be your therapy. 1 19 min. ago U realize that different tribes have different history right. We get it you think people w uteruses have no right to their own body. Go away now. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow If your tribe and your people historically have never supported abortion, ok? Nobody is saying the Yakama have. I was mentioning the fact that there ARE tribes thay historically have. And due to colonialism many people have been brainwashed into pro birth propaganda. 1 Any pro birth person is f------ weird it doesn't matter what their ethnic or racial background is. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 10 min. ago Your comments reek of condescending colonial privilege. You are acting like the very force you claim to oppose. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow

Emily enraged when Native American calls her out for orangewashing their history to fit her views on...


Uploaded by Reddit Moments Jun 25, 2022 at 11:30PM EDT

Share Pin Download More

Origin Entry: Political Compass

File type: jpg

Resolution: (1759px x 6123px)

File size: 802 KB


Authoritarian The immortal science of materialist Christianity made the master race dialectics is the only permitted world view. weak. Islam in particular must be destroyed. Economic- Left Imagine caring about anything. Economic- Right Sorry, but religion is, like, the patriarchy, sweetie. Slaves of the Archons Wanna buy a brain chip? Or at least a bottle of corn syrup? Libertarian Servants of the Aeons I hate the antichrist!
How is order maintained and the issue of economic scarcity dealt with? Authoritarian Government & Government Property Rights Economic- Left Economic- Right IDK (It's going to be a government) Property Rights Libertarian
LIBERTE EGALITE FRATERNITE FRATERNITE EGALITE LIBERTE
View All 53,171 Images


More:

0
0

Political Compass - Emily enraged when Native American calls her out for orangewashing their history to fit her views on...

PROTIP: Press the ← and → keys to navigate the gallery, 'g' to view the gallery, or 'r' to view a random image.


◄ Previous View Gallery Random Image Next ►

Moar:


+ Add a Comment

Comments (0)

There are no comments currently available.

Display Comments

Add a Comment


+ Add an Image

Image Details

206 views (6 from today)

Uploaded Jun 25, 2022 at 11:30PM EDT

Origin Entry

Political Compass

Source

Reddit

Tags

reddit, political compass memes, /r/politicalcompassmemes, font, material property

Claim Authorship Edit History
Textile Embed