I thought this 4chan greentext and comic panel had an entry, but apparently not.
I don't know which board this was, but it was posted August 6, 2012 and posted here on KYM on May 24, 2014 (I'm not sure if this screencap and panel were immediately popular or caught a second wind later, but this is the earliest KYM image I found):
For memetic proof, here are other KYM images which may belong in the entry:
'Hollow Knight: Silksong' Believers Have Been Applying Clown Makeup For Years