Option 1: Very attractive girl with whom you have a lot in common in terms of life experience, but with whom you would both be dirt poor, never mind the fact that you've never even spoken to her

Option 2: Very attractive girl in whom you have invested a great a deal of your time and energy and with whom you have saved a kingdom, which happens to be hers, because of whom you can live a life of luxury

I guess Esmerelda would have some appeal for Aladdin, but I'd still be sticking with Jasmine.

And they're both sworn enemies of the Catholic Church