Yo! You must login or signup first!

Sat, Feb 2, 11:29 AM FindStephen to Philipp Hi Philipp, Coffee Break here! I have some tough questions about the video on Addiction that Kurzgesagt did. It's one of your most popular videos with 18M views I'm worried that some of the major claims in that video are vastly oversimplified if not outright incorrect. Namely, the Rat Park results are oversimplified, and replicating B. Alexander's 1975 findings has had mixed results. And more troubling is the human "experiment" of vietnam. In his book, Hari paints a portrait of why soldier's got off their drugs. (they reconnected with their loved ones and got out of their "cage"). Upon further examination this seems incorrect. The person who actually conducted this study Lee Robins disagreed with explicitly with Hari's idea, and came to a much different conclusion for the lack of addiction. lack of availability of heroine, disapproval of friends etc... Now, I understand that the "addiction" video wasn't your typical video since you largely were animating a script from Hari himself, but I still have to ask: Did Kurzgesagt conduct an independent fact-checking of Johann Hari's book before agreeing to this? Were you aware at the time of the collaboration that Johann Hari had a public scandal in the past that threw his credibility into question? Were you paid to promote his book? If it turns out that Hari's major claims were fabricated or wrong, do you believe that Kurzgesagt is in part culpable for the spreading of misinformation? Especially in light of the fact that with 18M views, you've over tripled the distribution of Hari's main thesis in video format I want to be clear, I don't want to cause you concern. I'm not making a "gotcha" piece, I want to examine the role that "popularizers" like Hari, yourself and I play in society learning about science. And what responsibility we hold in making sure we "get the facts right". Your responsibility in this seems particularly unclear since you were mostly animating a script in this case. Thanks and I look forward to hearing back from you! Sincerely, Stephen

Email One


Uploaded by Sophie Mar 13, 2019 at 02:54PM EDT

Share Pin Download More

Origin Entry: Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

File type: jpg

Resolution: (1410px x 756px)

File size: 261 KB


America when the Japanese won't surrender: NUKE A CITY 8:56 grandayy What if We Nuke a City? 473K views 4 hours ago America when the Japanese still won't surrender: grandayy There is another
Dr Grandayy @grandayy Following This new Kurzgesagt vid is very informative What If We Detonated All Nuclear Bombs at Once? 460K views Kurzgesagt - In... SUBSCRIBED N 8.3M subscribers 7:32 AM-31 Mar 2019 1,279 Retweets 20,101 Likes
Coffee Break @coffeebreak YT св Replying to @The TierZoo I was busy releasing a new video and then got busy. I had no way of knowing I should be in a huge rush. I was about to get back with him when March 3rd hit. 12:19 PM-12 Mar 2019
View All 14 Images


Moar:


+ Add a Comment

Comments (0)

There are no comments currently available.

Display Comments

Add a Comment


+ Add an Image

Image Details

102 views (18 from today)

Uploaded Mar 13, 2019 at 02:54PM EDT

Origin Entry

Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

Tags

hari, addiction, philipp

Claim Authorship Edit History
Textile Embed