who would win

a terrible game that destroys he legacy of the previous and forces players to feel bad for being white/cis/male

one wingy angry staby sword boi

Yeah Ill admit the monent smash reveal happened I just bailed after to go do actual work related things and watched what was announced game wise later. I guess TLOU2 won a lot of awards it didnt seem to deserve but its not like TGA is more than a glorified back patting ceremony with ads anyway.
Of course an oscar bait game is going to win awards like this, and now that it has it can be fully relegated to the dust bin of forgotten sequels only known for its template memes and golf jokes.