Forums / Fun! / Forum Games

Before calling the town meeting, Bob naturally decided to rummage through Randy's belongings. He found $46.56 cash, embarrassing magazines, and a large collection of what appear to be small pony figurines. More importantly however, he found Randy's last words, which he must have written down the night before he died:

I dead sadface.jpg.
-
The latest death message tells us that the mafia was also possibly planning to kill my best friend Bob. I would advice the doctor to take this as a good hint on who to save the following night phases. Odds are that the mafia will then temporarily ignore Bob, but that’s ok so long as he remains alive. Of course you can’t clear Bob’s name, but it’s still something.

Now then, the hint again mentions two mafia. That’s a solid hint and can be compared to the first hint which stated “two shady figures”.

This possibly means that we’re dealing with 2 active mafia, and two silent ones.

We’ll use this to go back to the deduction I made after the first day, when we achieved a tie.

You had Team NON, Team Roarshack, and Team Other. Currently odds are that there is 1 mafia in Team NON, 1 in Team Roarshack, and 2 in Team Other. Of course this can’t be confirmed yet, but it’s the closest we got so far.

I would advice to continue with the deduction I made on the B-52 Bomber and vote for Arch Dornan.

If he turns out to be mafia, we can temporarily clear the names of everyone in Team Roarshack (as Arch Dornan was a Roarshack voter).

After that, check out Team Other, specifically the non-voters. As there are possibly two mafia in there, your odds of discovering on is the highest. Once you discover one, we can confirm Scenario 2 as truth.

Then look through Team NON, deduce who of its remaining voters are most likely to be a mafia. The recent hint mentioned “two mafia arguing”. Who amongst team NON is most likely to argue? Look into that (my bets are still on Chowz).

OOC:
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT REMINDER
The following players must vote during this phase or they will be removed from the game due to inactivity:
*Stalemate
*Max Burg IV
*justThisFool

In fact, the doctor did pay someone a visit last night, but for the sake of keeping things fair I can't tell you who.

I understand, doctor-patient confidentiality and all that.

I think Random Man was killed because of his knowledge of this case, and his superb sleuthing skills. I ofer my advice to the other Master Sluths out here, (Chowzs, Bob) keep the heads low. Not all of us are Master crime solvers. You're high value targets, they take you down, we're be like chickens with their heads cut off.

So, if three people are in danger of being booted, and we follow the theory that 2 mafioso are inactive; does that mean that the roles will be redistributed? Or will the mafia lose those members?

The mafia will most likely lose their members, so don't waste any votes on those three.

First off, I'd rather wait for an official answer from Crimea. Second, I still say we vote for Dornan. It's strange that you wouldn't want to follow the deductions made by both me and RM.

Also,

I ofer my advice to the other Master Sluths out here, (Chowzs, Bob) keep the heads low.

>Chowz
>Master sleuth
>Only contribution is getting an innocent killed

What?

I find it strange that you would hold chowz on a pedestal when his deductions only managed to lead us down the wrong path.

Random Man… ;_;
With Random Man's deductions, I guess Arch Donan is suspicious. I mean, he didn't say anything other than who he's voting against.
So, I'm voting for Arch Donan.

You've got to bold your votes. Put the name of the person you are voting for between two of these: *

Alright, it's fixed. Thanks!

We'll I'm dead because apparently being to tied to Navarro( an military base only Vertibirds no B-52s) makes me a suspect. However I did I find a lead, it seem that the people who are inactive during the day would be Mafia so I'll vote Just This Fool

In the event that any special role is inactive that role is essentially lost. It would be unfair to suddenly assign someone to be Mafia if they have already been ruled out by logic and reasoning since that would pretty much void any detective work that was done.

HolyCrapItsBob wrote:

I find it strange that you would hold chowz on a pedestal when his deductions only managed to lead us down the wrong path.

What's strange? He is one of the few people besides you to actually have an idea of what's going on. I'm trying to wrap my head around this as well, but I'm not as clever as you two.

All I can say is that the clues are probably larger than they seem.

fuck it i'm voting Chowz

You know what I'm changing to Chowz

No, people. Vote Arch Dornan

He doesn't have any B-52 things, was active for the past rounds, and hasn't been giving us problems before. He's innocent! If anything I'd focus on the other users who haven't been that active.

And I'm telling you that both RM and I believe he is guilty. RM has been proven innocent through death.

Are you really going to go against two "master sleuths"?

It seen to be a key word on "believe" even though there's no hard evidence on me and for we know you(Bob) could be the leader of the Mafia who got Random man killed so you could frame me.

You sound like my boyfriend with that last line.

While I'm not going against you, I am thinking that we might want to investigate more. The only lead we all seem to be going on is the B-52 one, and Arch already said he has nothing to do with those. There are still a few more people under suspicion, like those who haven't voted, those who only post when they need too, and the ones on that list Random Man made.

@Arch Dornan

And what makes you so sure that chowz is mafia? Need I remind you that I delivered NON to the citizens? If I was mafia, why would I give up the most important role for mafia? Your logic makes no sense.

@Hackenbacker

And I'm telling you I've got everything I need to make the call. I'm just asking you people to believe me. Though, your unwillingness to is being noted.

@HolyCrapItsBob

"Your unwillingness is being noted"
HA!
you don't have any evidence and you bloody want us to hang an innocent?

I just said that I know. How I know? I won't say. That would be giving too much away.

You seem very eager to throw away the opinion of someone who has gotten us a mafia kill already.

If it takes your mind off of me, and possibly spares my life, Bob, I'm willing to work as your handmaiden. I'd rather keep good in your light than be in your sites.

Although my final vote will come later….

you think your the one who got us the mafia kill.
really?
what i'm complaining is that we have no evidence.
but you know what fuck it
My votes now on Arch Dornan

We can make a tie if no one agrees…

Chowz

I'm voting for Arch Dornan.

Just a heads up guys, I'm busy for pretty much all of tomorrow so the next phase won't begin until some time in the late evening (mountain time).

Voting for Arch Dornan.

i vote Max Burg IV

Fuck I'm voting for Arch Dornan, hopefully Dornan won't be another Twisty.

Arch

When I see The Great Todd Howard you guys will regret putting me to the block

Arch Dornan

Is that a Confession?

I'm voting on Arch

I change my vote to Sergeant Arch Dornan

Is Arch confessing that he's a mafia member or are we about to do what we did to Twisty?

He's innocent, I'm voting for Burg, I think he means that we'll regret it. The only people we'd regret executing are the citizens or the doctor or anyone on our side.

DAY 3: July 2, 1934

The town somberly gathers once more to discuss who has committed this series of horrible crimes. Everyone seems more emotional and worked up than usual, possibly due to the loss of Randy who had proved to be very helpful in past meetings. Bob reads the last words of Randy to the crowd and posits that they should honor his last wishes and go after Sergeant Arch Dornan, a retired military officer from Navarro Airbase, north of San Fransisco. Despite his best efforts to divert their anger towards someone else, the vote is almost unanimously against Arch with the only holdouts being himself and Hannah Baker, who worked at the local dry cleaner. Mysteriously, the town Fool never showed up to the trial and no one was able to find him anywhere after hours of searching. This didn't really bother anyone though since he was a simple Citizen (even if he was drunk most of the time). Although most rational people would wish to check Arch's belongings before his execution, the crowd was not in a rational mood and took him straight to the electric chair. In this case, irrationality proved to not be an issue since a search of his corpse turned up a gun as well as one of the small pony figures which Bob identifies as having belonged to Randy before his demise. Sergeant Arch Dornan, it would seem, had retired to the Mafia.

NIGHT PHASE: 38 Hours Remain

Just a couple notes folks.

First of all, sorry about the late post. I was at the Calgary Stampede today getting my cowboy on (not in a gay way).

Second, the next night phase is going to be a bit longer as well in order to get back to the original schedule (I could have made it a 14 hour phase but that wouldn't be fair to the special roles who need to send me PMs).

Thirdly, justThisFool has been removed from the game. He was a Citizen. Unfortunately, the vote he posted during the last night phase does not count as activity since the purpose of the rule is to make sure people are participating in a meaningful way.

Alright! Now if we follow Random Man's deduction, there should be:

Team NON:
- Chowz
- Roarshack (Dead: One of the Fuzz)
- Bob
- Laud Piestrings
- Hackenbacker
Team Roarshack:
- No Original Names (Dead: The Spy)
- Mr Stalker
- KYFPMM
- Arch Dornan (Now Dead: Mafia Member)
- Freelancer
Team Other:
- RandomMan (Voted)
- Medamonster (Voted)
- Crow (Voted)
- Stalemate
- ShiJo
- Twisty (Dead: Citizen)
- Max Burg IV
- justThisFool (Now removed: Citizen)

So if we follow scenario 2: There should be 1 mafia member in "Team NON" and 2 in "Team Other".

Yes, we were right!

Good work everyone!

Guys, I noticed something as it relates to the people who voted for NON. Hackenbacker did NOT vote for Arch. Laud originally had me at first, then she voted for Arch. I doubt Bob is a mafia, so my guess for the mafia member on Team NON is none other than Hackenbacker.

I might want to note that 3 people refused to vote for Arch
. Hackenbacker
. Stalker
. Chowz

I voted for Arch. Go back to the previous page.

Well, if you excuse me, I'm going to go reinforce my home and business's windows and doors, probably make up my last will and testament, tell my beloved I love him, make peace with ym gods, and wait till the mob or the crowd eventually gets me.

Also, hate to double post here, but if you all do plan on killing me, I'd prefer firing squad over Ol'Sparky. I prefer to die on my feet.

Honestly though, aside fron been swooned and blindsided by a pretty boy's sob story (And honestly which girl hasn't?) and manipulated to speak on his behalf, why would you want me dead? Only the two of us voted to save his life. Unless the mafia voted him off for some reason, I suggest looking at the people who didn't vote.

Three things.

• Congratulations everyone.

• Hackenbacker is most suspicious at this moment, but I'll see how it plays out

• Most important point. DOCTOR, KEEP ME ALIVE TONIGHT.

NIGHT 4: July 3, 1934

That night everyone sleeps a little more soundly, knowing that they have brought one of the killers to justice. Unfortunately for them, three killers still remain. During the night one of the murderers acts alone and breaks into Bob's house as he slept.

The next day, the Doctor decides to pay Bob a visit after receiving a paranoid letter from him saying that he believed his life was in danger. He believes Bob is just being paranoid until he knocks on the door an hears nothing but a stifled moan in response. Frantically, the doctor rushes inside and finds Bob laying on the floor with several stab wounds. He quickly calls an ambulance and treats the most major wounds himself. Had the doctor not been there Bob would likely have died.

DAY PHASE: 24 Hours Remain

Nice work, Doc! That means that Bob is not a mafia member.
What's odd is that, Hackenbacker once said: "I think Random Man was killed because of his knowledge of this case, and his superb sleuthing skills. I ofer my advice to the other Master Sluths out here, (Chowzs, Bob) keep the heads low. Not all of us are Master crime solvers. You’re high value targets, they take you down, we’re be like chickens with their heads cut off."

Alright, so the clue says: "one of the murderers acts alone"
That PROBABLY means that it must be someone in "Team Other".

So, instead of doing a unanimous vote for Hackenbacker, we should do a vote for one of the people who voted for other? Well, nice work, Doc!

Well, now that my name has been cleared. I'm asking that the doctor and the remaining member of the fuzz contact me via PM.

Let's see if we can get this sorted out.