The first instance of this meme arose in the year 2015, beginning of the 2015/16 premier league football season. On the 4chan board /sp/ (sports). It started with a single thread entitled, "ETERNAL BLUE MOON THREAD" with the original poster showing a dutch flag. It was started with the intention of discussing the team Manchester City.

The poster regularly posted the same thread with hopes of discussing his team, however the Dutch Bandwagoner (as he was dubbed) was regularly mocked and insulted due to his choosing of the football team that would win trophies. He kept posting the thread throughout the season despite this. In one thread the Dutch Bandwagoner posted a picture of himself in one of his threads around the month of November (which is usually regarded as a bad move on 4chan). This led to hundreds of photoshopped images of him in various scenarios involving either Man City or showing him in a negative light in regards to his reason for supporting the club.

As such The Dutch Bandwagoner stopped posting the threads as much but Anonymous users would "Dutchpost" which involves the posting of the previously mentioned photoshopped images and further mocking the user for his appearance and his club.