Backlash Over "Game of Thrones" Showrunners' New Show Begins

July 20th, 2017 - 2:55 PM EDT by Matt Schimkowitz

45 comments | Contact Newsroom

Game of Thrones Showrunners, D.B. Weiss and David Benioff posing for pictures at the Game of Thrones premiere standing before a Game of Thrones backdrop.

It's been less than 24 hours since HBO announced a new series from the showrunners of Game of Thrones, and it's already inspired anger from all corners of the internet. Surprisingly, they didn't even need to cast Ed Sheeran.

HBO gave the green light to Confederate, a new series from D.B. Weiss and David Benioff about an alternate history in which slavery never ended because the southern states successfully seceded from the Union. This leads to a Third American Civil War and a cross section of characters fighting across the Mason-Dixon Demilitarized Zone.

Considering the current ease with which Americans discuss issues of slavery, racism and civil rights, this will probably fly right under the radar. Oh, there's already a backlash? Right, that makes sense.

Taking to Twitter, many have already commented on the show, particularly the potentially dangerous imagery and subject matter of a series like this from writers already known for their, let's say, less than delicate handling of sex, violence and race. Needless to say, the buzz is not positive, and it's drawing very few defenders.





These guys seem to stir a controversy without even trying.

This recent one comes hot on the heels of Weiss and Benioff irritating most of Westeros with an appearance from pop-singer Ed Sheeran on the season premiere of Thrones. Sheeran, who played a sweet singing soldier, quit Twitter for several days following his appearance. Though unconfirmed, many speculate that he left over criticism his cameo. After all, he has criticized Twitter in the past. "I go on it and there's nothing but people saying mean things," Sheeran said. "Twitter's a platform for that."

James Podeswa, the Sheeran episode's director, said of Sheeran: "He is one of the nicest guys in the world, and he really is one of the guys. He’s lovely, he’s a team player, he wants to do a good job, he takes direction, he’s very open. He’s a big fan of the show and he was really excited to be a part of it. I think his lovely voice was used to great effect and he just has a really nice presence. He blends into the world of the show in a nice way where if you didn’t have all these associations with him and his musical career, nobody would even blink about his presence on the show."

The Internet, by and large, however, had one word for this and the new show:


Top Comments

Sunnie Bot v4
Sunnie Bot v4

What the fuck are people getting outraged about? The show isn't calling for us to bring slavery back, it's exploring the idea of alternate history which is something that's been around for literally decades. Should we ban Man in the High Castle because facism extended for several more decades in that universe? How about Alternate History Hub? I'm really considering the idea that's there's a world wide gas leak that's just making people infinitely more retarded as reality.

+40
Nedhitis
Nedhitis

I am no GoT expert, but was it not always about conflict and war..? Is not slavery, then, a good theme to represent both..? There are countless movies about the horrors of real-life war, strong imagery and actual references included, without people decrying them on any aspect. Why is semi-fictional slavery a no-go, then..? A lot of these things are based on how life was in the past, and life in the past was not nice.

Then there is Marvel. They are pioneers when it comes to alternate universes where shit went wrong, some of which also include real-life negative themes. Again, nobody ever lifted a finger about those. Why can GoT not do the same..?

+9

+ Add a Comment

Comments (45)


Display Comments

Add a Comment


Hey! You must login or signup first!