Twitter Updates Its Privacy Policy, With Many Speculating It's In Response To The Stonetoss Doxxing

March 22nd, 2024 - 12:45 PM EDT by Adam Downer

5 comments | Contact Newsroom

A meme of Elon Musk checking Stonetoss in reference to his doxxing.

Twitter has once again courted controversy with a policy update that to some appears designed to protect right-wing extremists on the app, setting off another wave of discourse in recent days.

Earlier this week, Twitter, or X, updated its privacy policy to ban the revealing of a person's name if it is not publically available on the app. "The identity of an anonymous user, such as their name or media depicting them" is now a protected item on Twitter if it deems that information is shared "with abusive intent, or to harass another person."

While not directly referenced in the update, many online have speculated it was made due to the recent and highly publicized doxxing of StoneToss by an Antifa collective.

Last week, the group used a mix of articles and social media post history to suggest that the name of the controversial webcomic artist was someone named "Hans Kristian Graebener." Technically, they did so without using information that was not public and did not post Graebener's address or other personal details, nor did they post pictures that weren't on Graebener's social media accounts.

However, they were still banned from the platform, prompting a piece in Wired about Twitter's perceived scramble to stem the spread of information released in the StoneToss dox. The day after that story was published, Twitter updated its privacy policy.

DaithAIGilbert's update

Many believe the timing of this new rule indicated that it will be applied selectively to protect right-wing extremists and figures online, though this is merely conjecture. They argued that the practice of revealing someone's anonymous identity with the intent to court harassment has been liberally practiced by accounts including LibsOfTikTok and Andy Ngo for years while Twitter did not punish them.

For example, in early October, Ngo published the name and state of Juniper, a popular left-wing irony account, which had been posted on the app previously by two other accounts with smaller followings, though they did not mention the state of residence.

Andy Ngo Outs Juniper

The update was perceived by many on the platform to be further proof of Elon Musk's supposed whims towards making Twitter a hub for right-wing ideas in contrast to his stated commitment to "free speech."

The whims of Elon Musk Freedom of speech for me, not for thee

Meanwhile, on Tuesday, Musk shared yet another video that critics have argued pushes the Great Replacement Theory. In November, he caused advertisers to back out of Twitter by amplifying a Great Replacement Theory conspiracist.

Editor's Note: A small portion of this article was edited on March 25th to provide clarification on a statement made.


Top Comments

Revic
Revic

I've got no problem with this policy change unto itself. Perfectly reasonable change to make. But it's awfully exasperating that it only came about, after so many other people going through the same thing were utterly ignored, because Elon Musk saw a chance to ingratiate himself further to the only people who seem to tolerate him these days. It's like when a politician finally decides to take action on something they should have ages ago because it finally affected someone close to them. And the someone in question is an asshole. We'll see if the actual enforcement ends up as selective as the implementation. I expect to see a lot of mumbling inaction and circuitous justifications made if one of Musk's favorites runs afoul of it, but maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised.

+10
Luzno Lindo
Luzno Lindo

This seems like yet another case of people not agreeing with a privacy policy until they are the ones who end up having their privacy violated. Once they are the ones with their real names and such out in the open, there is not a doubt in my mind their tunes would change immediately.

+9

+ Add a Comment

Comments (5)


Display Comments

Add a Comment


Greetings! You must login or signup first!