Botched Ecce Homo Painting

Botched Ecce Homo Painting

Updated Aug 14, 2013 at 03:47PM EDT by Brad.  

Added by LeCalum.

Entry
Like Know Your Meme on Facebook!

PROTIP: Press 'i' to view the image gallery, 'v' to view the video gallery, or 'r' to view a random entry.

Overview

Botched Ecce Homo Painting, also known as “Potato Jesus”, refers to the failed restoration of a century-old Spanish devotional fresco, executed by elderly amateur art restorer Cecilia Jiménez. The result of the botched restoration spawned a photoshop meme, in which the ruined painting was edited in to other famous works of art, movie scenes or other memetic images.

Background

On August 21st, 2012, the Spanish publication Heraldo[2] published an article about a failed painting restoration performed by an elderly woman named Cecilia Jiménez. Jiménez wished to restore a damaged fresco created by Spanish painter Elías García Martínez named Ecce Homo (“Behold the Man”)[8], which was donated to the Santuario de Misericordia Church in the Spanish town of Borja. According to the church, Jiménez restored the painting without permission. However, she has claimed the priest allowed her to do so. After assessing the damage caused by the restoration, the church announced they would be hiring a professional to attempt to undo the botched job. Following the press coverage of the painting, Jimenez was reported to have been suffering from crippling anxiety attacks, reluctant to eat or leave her home.[17]



Notable Developments

Online Reaction

On August 21st, 2012, Redditor rolmos submitted a post to /r/pics[5] titled “An old church in Spain needed to restore a worn out painting. They hired the wrong person”, which included photographs of the painting before and after it was altered. Within two days, the post received over 11,000 upvotes and 750 comments. Redditor donosti replied to the post with an edited version of the failed restoration made to appear as if it were an illustration of a lion (shown below, left). On August 22nd, a 4chan thread nicknamed the painting “Potato Jesus” (shown below, right), which referenced the I Can Count to Potato image macro series. The thread was not archived.



On August 22nd, a Facebook group titled Beast Jesus Restoration Society[10] was created, receiving 4050 likes in just under two weeks. The creators started a single topic Tumblr[11] the following day dedicated to photoshopped images featured on the Facebook page. Also on the 23rd, a Twitter account @FrescoJesus[16] was created, gaining nearly 7000 followers in two weeks. By mid-September, the restored painting had been featured by major English-language news outlets as well as other newspapers in 160 countries worldwide.




Change.org Petition

On August 22nd, a Change.org petition[12] was created, urging officials not to remove Jiménez’s restoration, calling the botched painting “daring” and looking at it as an example of the Expressionism art movement. As of August 31st, the petition has 22,185 signatures out of the 25,000 it is asking for. The petition was also shared on the Huffington Post[13], MSN.com[14] and Gawker.[15]

The Cecilia Prize

On August 24th, 2012, a restoration generator app known as the Cecilia Prize[6] was launched by creative team BBH London, along with a competition to see who could come up with the best interpretation of the painting. The image submissions were then funneled into a Pinterest board[7] (shown below) and a Twitter feed with the hashtag #ceciliaprize.[9] The contest was covered by the Huffington Post[17], AdWeek[18] and CNet[19], noting that the winner would receive a poster of the original painting.



Impact

Jiménez’ infamous restoration has had a positive impact on the Spanish town of Borja. According to the local news reports, The Santuario de Misericordia Church has drawn more than 40,000 visitors and raised at least €50,000 euros (USD $66,285) for a local charity since implementing an entrance fee of one euro per visitor nearly a year ago.



Royalty Dispute

On September 19th, 2012, Spanish newspaper El Correo[18] reported that Gimenez has claimed copyright on her restoration and is demanding royalties from the Santi Spiritus Hospital Foundation, the church organization that owns the restored painting. Speaking on behalf of Gimenez, one of her attorneys Enrique Trebolle explained that the client “just wants the church to conform to the law” and would like to donate the proceedings towards Muscular atrophy charities. On August 13th, 2013, almost a year later, Spanish newspaper Heraldo de Aragon reported that the local council of Borja and Gimenez will sign a deal in the coming week to share profits from souvenir merchandise featuring the botched image, entitling Gimenez to 49 percent of the total revenues.



In reacting to the revenue deal, Gimenez was quoted as saying:

“Now it seems like everyone’s happy, I’m grateful that things have quieted down.”

Notable Examples



Search Interest



External References

[1]elEconomista.es – Una anciana de Borja restaura mal un fresco… y consigue la mofa en Twitter

[2]Heraldo.es – La ‘restauración’ de una pintura mural en una iglesia de Borja acaba en chapuza

[3]La Voz de Galicia.es – La restauradora: «El cura lo sabía»

[4]Facebook.com – Facebook page

[5]Reddit – An old church in Spain needed to restore a worn out painting. They hired the wrong person.

[6]The Cecilia Prize – The Cecilia Prize

[7]Pinterest – Cecilia Prize Gallery

[8]Wikipedia – Ecce Homo (Elías García Martínez)

[9]Twitter – #ceciliaprize

[10]Facebook – Beast Jesus Restoration Society

[11]Tumblr – Beast Jesus

[12]Change.org – Ayuntamiento de Borja (Zaragoza): Mantenimiento de la nueva versión del Ecce Homo de Borja

[13]Huffington Post – ‘Ironic Art Fans’ Petition To Save World’s Worst Restoration Of ‘Ecce Homo’

[14]MSNPetition implores town to save woman’s awful restoration job

[15]Gawker – Thousands Sign Petition to Save Worst Fresco Touch Up Ever as Elderly Woman Responsible Speaks

[16]Twitter – @FrescoJesus

[17]El Mundo – La anciana ‘restauradora’ del Ecce Homo, en cama por un ataque de ansiedad

[18]El Correo – Cecilia is now demanding royalties for destroying the ‘Ecce Homo’

[19]Huffington Post – ‘Ecce Homo’ Restorationist Cecilia Gimenez Allegedly Demands Royalties For ‘Beast Jesus’ Creation In Spain

[20]The Telegraph – Elderly woman who botched religious fresco demands royalties

[21]Slate – Elderly Woman Who Accidently Turned a Priceless Fresco Into a Viral Hit is Suing For Royalties

Recent Videos 24 total

Recent Images 768 total

Top Comments


+ Add a Comment

Comments 151 total

Loading-blocks-red

+ Add a Comment

Add a Comment

O HAI! You must login or signup first!