I LOATHE the image bots/mass uploaders (mainly Jaimie Hamilton and Reddit Moments). They seem to be above the rules and yet contribute nothing to make up for it.
Sometimes I try uploading something and it turns out that it's a duplicate, which is a good feature because I don't want to upload duplicates, and it seems that's a sentiment shared across this site. But the bots always end up uploading visual duplicates because I'm pretty sure the anti-duplicate code only checks the source link, and it's infuriating because they're breaking a rule that everyone else has to follow.
Everything they upload is from Reddit too, which is my personal largest gripe. While there's nothing wrong with uploading from Reddit, the bots are a particular issue because more than 50% of the time the images are Reposts, meaning the provided link isn't even the original source. And as someone who was inspired by cases of bad tagging and sourcing on this very website to become someone who wants to source everything, it's just really dissapointing for inaccurate sources to be spread.
However, perhaps the biggest issue (and one that came from Pyroniusburn in this very thread, perhaps even informing my entire opinion on it) is the fact that they are highly anti-thetical to a meme research website, and mostly redundant for a documentation website. As Pyroniusburn mentioned, subreddits can't really evolve since they focus entirely on one kind of thing. Sure, they may generate some trends or injokes (which are, in fact, memes and memetic mutation) such as that Red Drought over in r/SurrealMemes, and those can spread to the general Online public. But having subreddit-specific entries be constantly filled with stuff overplays their importance in the creation of memes (seriously, why is there an /r/freefolk entry still getting images, for a subreddit that discusses Game of Throne spoilers, when we already have a Game of Thrones entry?!?!).
This also leads into the problem with there being an entry for every TikTok trend because there's no way to determine if those will start a new long-lasting meme or not, but that's a topic for a different post.
EDIT: I forgot to talk about if they really are important. I'm not sure about the Reddit Moments bot, but Jaimie Hamilton actually does write things under the Editorial Collections, so it's not nothing (the other staff mass-uploaders also likely contribute to the Editorials; also not nothing). However, Jaimie seems to pull entirely from Reddit for the memes they put on a pedestal, which still makes me sad.
I also forgot how I'd want these issues addressed.
I would like Reddit Moments shutdown, and at least a greater mix of websites to pull from for the Editorials that pay the bills (Twitter, Tumblr, Reddit, 4chan if you must).