Enchanted Portals Cuphead Controversy

Enchanted Portals Cuphead Controversy

Part of a series on Cuphead. [View Related Entries]

Updated Oct 24, 2019 at 03:56AM EDT by andcallmeshirley.

Added Oct 10, 2019 at 03:06PM EDT by Matt.

PROTIP: Press 'i' to view the image gallery, 'v' to view the video gallery, or 'r' to view a random entry.

This submission is currently being researched & evaluated!

You can help confirm this entry by contributing facts, media, and other evidence of notability and mutation.

Overview

The Enchanted Portals-Cuphead Controversy refers to a series of critical comparisons between the 2017 video game Cuphead and the upcoming video game Enchanted Portals. Many have noted the similarities in animation and gameplay styles, leading many to accuse Portals of copying ideas from Cuphead. The developers of Enchanted Portals have defended their game, calling the similarities intentional and asserting that Cuphead inspired their game.

Background

On October 8th, 2019, the Twitter account for the video game Enchanted Portals tweeted the tailer for the developer's "upcoming kickstarter campaign." The post received more than 1 million views, 9,000 likes and 1,800 retweets in 24 hours (shown below).

Developments

Online Reaction

Following the release of the trailer, many reacted negative to what they recognized as similarities to Cuphead. For example, Twitte[1] user @EpicFunnyName tweeted an image an interface message from the game Fallout that reads, "You've been caught pickpocketing" (shown below, left).

The following day, Twitter[2] user @streetgrind_ tweeted a series of side-by-side images from the two games. They captioned the images, "Enchanted Portals: Can I copy your homework? / Cuphead: Sure just make it look different so it doesn't look like you just copied it / Enchanted Portals: Sure thing. / BOYYYY if this isn't borderline plagiarism…" The tweet recieved more than 3,300 likes and 720 retweets in 24 hours (shown below, center).

Twitter[3] user @RiseFallNick shared a message from the developers of Enchanted Portals stating that they were inspired by Cuphead. @RiseFallNick wrote, "Look I wanna give Enchanted Portals the benefit of the doubt but… I can't, either can most of the community. It literally looks like they're trying to cash in on both look and gameplay of the pre-existing Cuphead, and that's not great. Fine line between inspiration and ripoff." Within 24 hours, the tweet received more than 2,000 likes and 400 retweets (shown below, right).


Enchanted Portals @PlayEnchanted Oct 8 Here's the trailer for our upcoming kickstarter campaign! #gamedev #indiegame 1:43 1.1M views t 1.8K 2.9K 9K Societal Jimmy @EpicFunnyName Replying to @PlayEnchanted You've been caught pickpocketing 10:20 PM Oct 8, 2019 Twitter Web App TRAFON @RiseFallNick Look I wanna give Enchanted Portals the benefit of the doubt but... I can't, either can most of the community. It literally looks like they're trying to cash in on both look and gameplay of the pre-existing Cuphead, and that's not great Fine line between inspiration and ripoff. tals We really appreciate head and were inspired by ar, but we're trying to give r own thing. The portals a even though it might not exciting content yet to be r t and for the good luck! #1 9:44 AM- Oct 9, 2019 Twitter Web Client

That day, YouTuber Jim Sterling published a review of the trailer, calling Enchanted Portals a "brazen" rip-off of Cuphead. The post received more than 180,000 views in 24 hours (shown below).



Developer's Response

The following day, speaking to Polygon,[4] two people from Xixo, the studio behind Enchanted Portals, defended the game. They said:

Yes, of course Cuphead was a huge inspiration for Enchanted Portals. We’re both avid fans and we wanted to make something similar, but always from a place of respect and admiration for the original.

We were prepared for some backlash, but the trailer definitely reached way more people than we could ever anticipate, and all the hate and negativity coming our way has definitely had a huge impact on us.

That being said, along with all those negative responses, a lot of people have also reached out to us to say they adore the game and they would love to see it succeed. So we’re trying to turn our attention more towards all those who are supporting us and sending their love for the game.

Search Interest

Not available.

External References

Recent Videos 3 total

Recent Images 9 total


Top Comments

Nedhitis
Nedhitis

More importantly, what is the opinion of Cuphead's creator about this..? Because what we all bunch of randoms with pitchforks say is completely pointless compared to his opinion on this matter. In fact, has anyone even tried to ask him for his opinion about this, or did we just jump directly to the crucifixion part..?

Not convinced..? Then look up "Heartbound" and the story behind it. Long story short: a game inspired by Undertale, but it wanted to be its own thing and, as it turns out, Tobyfox himself came up to the public defense of the game on his Twitter account when people started treating it as either an Undertale clone or drawing too many comparisons with Undertale, even if well-intentioned, since it made it sound like the game existed on Undertale's shadow despite being its own, ambitious project.

So yes, as for me, I admit that the game looks too similar to Cuphead, perhaps more than needed, but ultimately, it is up to Cuphead's creator to decide whether or not to make a move about this being plagiarism or a faithful fan-inspired work. Literally and legally speaking, mind you. And I am rather disappointed, but not surprised, that nobody seems to care about his opinion about this and basically speak on his behalf instead.

+134
Molemanninethousand
Molemanninethousand

So what's the controversy? "Clone" games happen all the time and that's completely okay; if anything I'd imagine that fans of Cuphead would naturally love this.

+72

+ Add a Comment

Comments (165)


Display Comments

Add a Comment


Hey! You must login or signup first!