Hi! You must login or signup first!

Shirtstorm / Shirtgate

Added 10 years ago / Updated 4 days ago
Matt_taylor_esa_shirt

Confirmed   113,782

Shamrock95 +4 4. 0 08-18-201515:50 AM The reality, of course, was that a guy did a thing, realized it, and had the f------ integrity, dignity, and bravery to admit he was wrong. No, Sargent. The reality is that this man's monumental achievement in science and astronomywas undermined by a bunch of squawking feminist idiots who couldn't see any further than the damn shirt he was wearing, and proceeded to forever tarnish what should have been a wonderful moment of triumph for him. Why? Because they were labouring under the delusion that they have the right not to be offended. People weren't angry about it because of political correctness, they were angry about it because it's a perfect example of the petty and mindless BS that passes for third-wave feminism. When people make fun of SJWs, they're not talking about the people who are standing up for genuinely good and noble causes to defend the rights of minorities. They're talking about the keyboard commandos who have nothing better to do than try and stir up outrage over someone's choice of clothing or how they choose to sit on a f------ bus. Those people deserve NOTHING but scorn, and anybody who thinks hemigt be onto somngd tdusional at worst Reply
The video-game industry has a dress code Article say bullshirt for lack of memory and willing ignorance Article say bullshirt for lack of driven by a lack of diversity Holly Nielsen And do not forget double standards I wasn't expecting a young, vibrant creative world to have a uniform. But there is an insidious pressure to fit in, and it involves plaid and denim ost professions have a uniform of some kind, whether it's the suit and tie of corporate culture, or the brand-asserting mono-wear of the world'smajor retail outlets. Sometimes, however, dress codes can be much more insidious. In the world ofvideo games, a young creative industry that seek assert its rebelliousness and vibrancy, we are required to conform through essity or tradition. But one thing I discovered very quickly when I started working here is that there is a uniform: it's just that this one is the result, not of workplace CD rules, but of a lack of diversity, And it can. be just as excluding It was the night of my very first launch party. I'd just finished my internship at a vide s Iy channel and I was goin g through the familiar routine of ch oosing an outfit In other wordsI was trying on everything in my own wardrobe as well as the wardrobes of all my flatmate special occasion: a patterned mid-length dress with black panels down the side. I sent a photo of it to the colleague who'd invited me, but her replied surprised me: "It's lovely but a bit too dressy for tonightI wore it an When we arrived at the event, Irealised straight away that she was right.Iwas greeted with a sea of plaid and denim, amid which you could sormetimes pick out the odd T-shirt, usually bearing a video game or movie reference so obscure only the wearer and four of their friends would ever understand it. There were barely any wormen there, and most of those were publishers or in marketing, rather than developers. I felt like a lone speck of femininity in a musty fog of identikit men. ntually decided on something I'd been saving for a The white guy in checked shirt, jeans and trainers.Possibly with a beard. It's the joke we often make about the industry, but there is plenty of truth in the stereotype. This tweet from developer 2K Games (although clearly a joke) pretty much sums things up Just another day at the 2K offices... pic.twitter.com/PZs1VRsli Go to any games event, whether its a major premiere or an indie expo, and the room will be filled with people in this ensemble. It's not that men shouldnt dressa lumberjacks, everyone deserves the freedom to wear what they want, but the unremitting casualness of the games industry has almost become a stifling uniform in itself. Most of the time, you'll only ever see anything smarter at a formal event, like the Bafta awards - and even then, we're talking hired Moss Bros suits or emergency polyester purchases from the nearest budget clothing outlet. In thisindustry, "smart" means wearing your box-fresh Adidas Sambas rather than those battered Converse with the sole flapping off. I'm fond of dresses, but whenever I dared wear one to the office I would be met with a chorus of "what's the occasion?" Follow Maybe hypocrite feminist @ should clean our her own closet before slut ered the games industry as a 19-year-old woman, facing a professional shaming a man's choice of attire environment dominated by men. In its 2014 workplace study, the International Game Developer Association found that the number of women in the industry has doubl in the past five years, but it still stands at just 22%. And at industry events it can feel like a lotless. I was acutely aware of standing out, the clothes I liked to wear didn't fit in with the consensus of casual boyishness. Consequently, I found myself consciously wearing more androgynous outfits, my dresses and skirts were pushed to the back of the wardrobe, and I started choosing plainer clothes that I wouldn't have reall considered before. Goodbye beloved floral A-line dress, hello plain black T-shirt esa particularly self conscious of As a woman who often appears in front of cameraI was choosing anything that could be considered "sexy".I was once told by a seasoned industry professional that they wer stream video together as they didn't want to look like they were "selling sex" Somehow, internet c that my body wasn't something that belonged to me, butto those who looked at me The way to combat that was to tone down the way I dressed. To be taken seriously asa video games journalist, I had to avoid looking "sexy" or "girly e relucta et myself and a female collea ommenters started to have an influence-they made me think It's taken me over a year, along with meeting and befriending other inspirational women in the industry, to realise that changing my style so that I can fit in is wIong. A uniform implies control and regim where those constraints should not apply. Indeed, we are lucky to be part of a culture that is still forming its own identity - that can be a wonderful thing. We joke about the stereotypical games industr y look, but we need to be aware that it is the product of a lack of diver sity, both in terms of gender and ethnicity - as such it can seem just as exclusionary as the tailored suit and tie of the professional world Of course, m not saying that the whole industry nee more welcoming toward different concepts of style and identity. Creativity begins with how we feel and how we see and present ourselves as people. This industry isn't ust dressingidentically, it draws its inspiration from the same music, movies and books. Tis homogeneity leads to staid ideas. entation, and this is a young and creative industry, a makeover, butit has to be now happily wear my floral A-line dress to video game events, and yes, I do stand out, but that's fine. In an industry that lacks it, difference is a good thing to have
I KNOW, DUDE. THEY CALLED MY SHIRT A R--- JOKE.
In Man of Steel, besides a lot of things, there's this little exchange that happens at one time between Superman and Lois Lane Lois Lane: Why are you surrendering to Zod? Superman: I'm surrendering to mankind. There's a difference. Lois Lane: You let them handcuff you? Superman: Wouldn't be much of a surrender if I resisted. And if it makes them feel more secure, then... then all the better for it. Lois Lane: What's the S' stand for? Superman: It's not an 'S. On my world it means 'hope." Lois Lane: [smiles] Well, here it's an 'S." Does anyone else see how stupid this dialogue is? First off, Lois Lane is questioning an Alien. Living proof that there IS life outside of planet Earth. And what is she asking him? Not, "Are there other planets with life?" Not "How many light years away was your planet" Not "Can you consume the same food we do?" Or a thousand other relevant questions No, Lois Lane has to ask why he's wearing an "S Not only that, but Superman corrects her. He's not wearing an "S". He's wearing a symbol that, for his Alien culture, means "hope". But Lois Lane is not taking that crap! No! You take your stupid alien culture out of here, you Alien scum, here we speak American! That's an S! And then everyone is surprised when Superman is a d--- and destroys Metropolis while fighting Zod? I'm surprised he didn't help Zod kill everyone! I mean, what kind of idiot is in presence of one of the most amazing events in the history of Mankind regarding space exploration, but can only focus on a shirt?.. Oh, wait... のesa Acquisi VIA 9GAG.COM
T MANS SIRT IS OFFENSIVE S SEXIST DEALS AND DE-HUMANI 2ES VEMO6RAPHC! IT OBJECTIFIES AN EAND MAKES VwoMEN WANTIN6 NTER THE STEM FIELD FEL OMEN THREATENED! PIG Mi NAS A SHIRT.:. E THIS MAT? MALE TEARS Kル ArL ME THIS IS FEMINIST
Christina H. Sommers @CHSommers-Nov 24 res o fP ant oSate py who sd Mait Tayor for nis demeani ng & sexualized shirt.il am triggered. 2 1,164 ★1,028
View All 54 Images

Navigation
About • Background • Notable Developments • Search Interest • External References • Recent Images • Recent Videos

About

#Shirtstorm and #Shirtgate are Twitter hashtags that arose in reaction to a shirt worn by British scientist Dr Matt Taylor during livestream coverage of the spacecraft Philae's comet landing during the Rosetta Mission in November 2014.

Background

On November 12th 2014, European Space Agency spacecraft Philae achieved the first landing of a spacecraft on a comet in human history.[1] During Nature Newsteam’s livestream coverage of the landing, Rosetta scientist Matt Taylor was interviewed in a colorful bowling shirt featuring patterns of scantily clothed female cartoon characters (shown below).

Notable Developments

Twitter Reaction

That day, Brooklyn-based journalist Rose Eveleth tweeted a photograph of Taylor with a sarcastic remark citing his shirt as an example of the male-biased work culture within the scientific community (shown below). Also on November 12th, Taylor’s friend Elly Prizeman tweeted she made the shirt for Taylor’s birthday, accompanied by the hashtags “#shirtgate” and “#shirtstorm.”

* Elly PriZeMaN @ellypriZeMaN Follow I made a shirt for one of my close pals @mggtTaylor ik bir hiss b dlny. 131 d noi: 《踯3C3Gü this!! #shirtgate #shirtstorm #Rosetta #Shirt #sewing RETWEETSFAVORITES 1,281 1,171 圆 9:05 AM-13 Nov 2014

In the following 48 hours, the tweet gained over 1,000 retweets and 760 favorites, while the hashtags #shirtstorm and #shirtgate were mentioned more than 23,000 times and 19,000 times, respectively.

Rose Eveleth @roseveleth Follow No no women are toooootally welcome in our community, just ask the dude in this shirt. youtube.com/watch?v=NSv6ZB·.. わt3 esa AcquisltU 3

News Media Coverage

On November 13th, The Verge[14] published an article titled “I don’t care if you landed a spacecraft on a comet, your shirt is sexist and ostracizing,” which accussed Taylor of “the sort of casual misogyny that stops women from entering certain scientific fields.” The debacle was reported on several news websites such as CNN[4], The Telegraph,[5] Talking Points Memo,[6] Daily Mail[9] and The Guardian.[10]

Taylor's Apology

On November 14th, Taylor made a tearful apology for wearing the shirt during an ESA Google+ Hangout session (shown below).

“I made a big mistake and I offended many people and I am very sorry about this."

Online Debate

Many twitter users reused the hashtags to criticize the shallowness of the complaints. Prizeman, wrote a more thorough blog post[11] expressing her disappointment with those who reacted negatively toward Taylor.

Andrew Brooks @taxbod- 12h I'd wear what I damn well pleased. #ShirtGate わ £710 ★13 If I had a doctorate from Imperial, and had just landed a space thingy on a comet © Twitter

On November 17th, London mayor Boris Johnson made public statements defending Taylor, comparing his critics to "Islamist maniacs."[13]

Search Interest

External References

[1] Wikipedia – Philae Spacecraft

[2] Twitter – #shirtstorm

[3] Twitter – #shirtgate

[4] CNN – Philae researcher criticized for shirt covered in scantily clad women

[5] The Telegraph – Matt Taylor's sexist shirt and the day political correctness officially went mad

[6] Talking Points Memo – Rosetta Scientist Sparks #ShirtStorm With Scantily Clad Women On Shirt

[7] The Verge – I don't care if you landed a spacecraft on a comet, your shirt is sexist and ostracizing

[8] Stem Women – Astronomical Sexism: Rosetta #ShirtStorm and Everyday Sexism in STEM

[9] Daily Mail – Comet probe scientist breaks down in tears during live broadcast following criticism for his ‘sexist’ shirt featuring scantily clad women

[10] The Guardian – Rosetta scientist Dr Matt Taylor apologises for ‘offensive’ shirt

[11] Blogspot – Decisions and comments.

[12] Alohaland – New Gunner Girls SOLD OUT

[13] The Telegraph – Boris Johnson defends Rosetta scientist in shirt storm

Share Pin

Recent Images 54 total

View All Images

Recent Videos 4 total

View All Videos

Load 324 Comments
21
Shirtstorm / Shirtgate

Shirtstorm / Shirtgate

PROTIP: Press 'i' to view the image gallery, 'v' to view the video gallery, or 'r' to view a random entry.

About

#Shirtstorm and #Shirtgate are Twitter hashtags that arose in reaction to a shirt worn by British scientist Dr Matt Taylor during livestream coverage of the spacecraft Philae's comet landing during the Rosetta Mission in November 2014.

Background

On November 12th 2014, European Space Agency spacecraft Philae achieved the first landing of a spacecraft on a comet in human history.[1] During Nature Newsteam’s livestream coverage of the landing, Rosetta scientist Matt Taylor was interviewed in a colorful bowling shirt featuring patterns of scantily clothed female cartoon characters (shown below).


Notable Developments

Twitter Reaction

That day, Brooklyn-based journalist Rose Eveleth tweeted a photograph of Taylor with a sarcastic remark citing his shirt as an example of the male-biased work culture within the scientific community (shown below). Also on November 12th, Taylor’s friend Elly Prizeman tweeted she made the shirt for Taylor’s birthday, accompanied by the hashtags “#shirtgate” and “#shirtstorm.”


* Elly PriZeMaN @ellypriZeMaN Follow I made a shirt for one of my close pals @mggtTaylor ik bir hiss b dlny. 131 d noi: 《踯3C3Gü this!! #shirtgate #shirtstorm #Rosetta #Shirt #sewing RETWEETSFAVORITES 1,281 1,171 圆 9:05 AM-13 Nov 2014

In the following 48 hours, the tweet gained over 1,000 retweets and 760 favorites, while the hashtags #shirtstorm and #shirtgate were mentioned more than 23,000 times and 19,000 times, respectively.


Rose Eveleth @roseveleth Follow No no women are toooootally welcome in our community, just ask the dude in this shirt. youtube.com/watch?v=NSv6ZB·.. わt3 esa AcquisltU 3

News Media Coverage

On November 13th, The Verge[14] published an article titled “I don’t care if you landed a spacecraft on a comet, your shirt is sexist and ostracizing,” which accussed Taylor of “the sort of casual misogyny that stops women from entering certain scientific fields.” The debacle was reported on several news websites such as CNN[4], The Telegraph,[5] Talking Points Memo,[6] Daily Mail[9] and The Guardian.[10]

Taylor's Apology

On November 14th, Taylor made a tearful apology for wearing the shirt during an ESA Google+ Hangout session (shown below).



“I made a big mistake and I offended many people and I am very sorry about this."

Online Debate

Many twitter users reused the hashtags to criticize the shallowness of the complaints. Prizeman, wrote a more thorough blog post[11] expressing her disappointment with those who reacted negatively toward Taylor.


Andrew Brooks @taxbod- 12h I'd wear what I damn well pleased. #ShirtGate わ £710 ★13 If I had a doctorate from Imperial, and had just landed a space thingy on a comet © Twitter

On November 17th, London mayor Boris Johnson made public statements defending Taylor, comparing his critics to "Islamist maniacs."[13]

Search Interest

External References

[1] Wikipedia – Philae Spacecraft

[2] Twitter – #shirtstorm

[3] Twitter – #shirtgate

[4] CNN – Philae researcher criticized for shirt covered in scantily clad women

[5] The Telegraph – Matt Taylor's sexist shirt and the day political correctness officially went mad

[6] Talking Points Memo – Rosetta Scientist Sparks #ShirtStorm With Scantily Clad Women On Shirt

[7] The Verge – I don't care if you landed a spacecraft on a comet, your shirt is sexist and ostracizing

[8] Stem Women – Astronomical Sexism: Rosetta #ShirtStorm and Everyday Sexism in STEM

[9] Daily Mail – Comet probe scientist breaks down in tears during live broadcast following criticism for his ‘sexist’ shirt featuring scantily clad women

[10] The Guardian – Rosetta scientist Dr Matt Taylor apologises for ‘offensive’ shirt

[11] Blogspot – Decisions and comments.

[12] Alohaland – New Gunner Girls SOLD OUT

[13] The Telegraph – Boris Johnson defends Rosetta scientist in shirt storm

Recent Videos 4 total

Recent Images 54 total


Top Comments

Particle Mare
Delete
Sensitive
Particle Mare

The title of the Verge article, and I quote exactly, is "I don't care if you landed a spacecraft on a comet, your shirt is sexist and ostracizing".

Oh, for goodness sake. You think you're helping aspiring female scientists? You're not. When you tell someone that something as banal and superficial as a few spots of skin on a shirt is more worthy of attention than a spacecraft landing on a comet for the first time in human history, then don't be surprised if you end up destroying their passion for science instead of kindling it.

I'm training to become a scientist so I can challenge myself mentally and contribute to humanity. I, for one, could not care less if you believe that the design on some guy's shirt is oppressing me – I'm here to look at supernovas, not to listen to your petty bullshit. Go peddle it elsewhere, please.

+197
Reply

+ Add a Comment

Comments (324)


Display Comments

Add a Comment


Suggest a Change   Edit History