Super Smash Brothers - Super Smash Bros. for SNES

Well obviously, it's Blue Peach and Baby Mario.

I think I speak for the entire community when I say, I would love to drop kick my past self through a dimensional portal with a copy of Smash and a Wii U and show him its glory.
I was already blown away by Smash 64 at the time, I can only imagine my reaction to the HD graphics and 52 character roster.