Forums / Discussion / General

171,344 total conversations in 5,616 threads

+ New Thread


Featured Featured Locked Locked
KYM Pony General V: We Just Don't Know What Went Wrong

Last posted Jul 01, 2012 at 04:43PM EDT. Added Feb 19, 2012 at 11:27PM EST
9954 posts from 194 users




and i can easily imagine Octavia playing this piece. so far, one of my favorites out there.
(been getting into classical music lately. not that it’s bad or anything)

of all the musical ponies out there, Octavia’s my personal fav, with Vinyl a close second.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 02:10AM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 02:04AM EDT
Quote

@This music discussion

  1. As said before, she is standing bipedally and holding a bow with her hoof, thus making her stand out from the rest of the quartet. Add to that that her positition is also one of the center positions, making her appear more important.
  2. I wouldn’t really call her instrument that important, although she does still stand out the most. When it comes to classical music, I really love the violin and the piano. Both allow for great, more fast paced, sections. The piano being present but the violin not, I still like Octavia more than that piano player. Her instrument is also the only one that hasn’t received any changes so that ponies can use it compared to the versions humans use, making it appear more natural. That is an important factor to how bronies look at them, it gives Octavia a closer relation to humans indirectly.
  3. Her female part certainly is important. The most amount of characters on the show are still female. Plus given that most bronies are male, it’s pretty simple math.
  4. Looks are indeed important. All those four ponies gained the personality of being more classical ponies. With that a more classical look of course have to come. The two most right ponies have a somewhat weird color combination when it comes to classical music, coming more closer to the “pastal colored” theme of the standard pony. Plus their manes are also pretty standard. Of the two remaining ponies, Octavia is the female. Going back to point 3, this already gives her an advantage. Plus her somewhat grey coat with black mane really make her appear as a more cool and classical type of pony. Add to that her unique mane compared to your standard background pony, and you have a popular fanonization.

If I would look at the four without knowing their fanon connections, if I was an artist I would prefer to draw Octavia based on the looks. Knowing the actual artists might think like this as well, it makes sense that more fanart of her appears. Fanart is of course also a very important factor in the brony culture. As for background ponies, they often decide how we look at them.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 02:37AM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 02:26AM EDT
Quote

Oh what, we haven’t reached 200 pages yet? Come on people, chop chop. Get some moar posts in.


Also, a few pages late, but this:

When the hell were there so many Polish bronies?

And Finland? I blame Muumi.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 03:28AM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 03:24AM EDT
Quote

I demand the government release the name of this Citizen so we may execute MOB JUSTICE!

Jun 25, 2012 at 05:11AM EDT
Quote

Yes, Octavia’s got that certain something.


@Twins

You know what surprises me is actually how many Mexican bronies there are. I don’t know why I find that interesting. Maybe it’s because the show is so different in my mind from TV shows that are made domestically in Mexico.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 05:12AM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 05:12AM EDT
Quote

@I post stuff

You thought wrong. While most bronies are from the US, at least, if the Equestria Daily map of how many people accessed their site for the 200,000,000 hits is accurate, that doesn’t mean Britain has very few. They actually have a lot. If what I hear is true, it’s already surpassed popularity as opposed to the Twilight Saga (finally, Sparkly Twilight is more popular than Sparkly Vampires, and it’s official)

Jun 25, 2012 at 10:01AM EDT
Quote

I wish I was a painter.

Last night I dreamed of a night sky more beautiful than our own, filled with brilliant purple and jade and other celestial colors. You could see the dance of the planets and the stars and the galaxies.

I would paint that otherworldly night sky and show it to Luna and ask her “U mad?”

“Bitch please, have some photographs.”



Jun 25, 2012 at 10:06AM EDT
Quote

@Brony population
I remember Verbose’s and Opspe’s survey had that most bronies lived in the United States. I would guess it’s because trends of any sort seem to be largest there. I think the nearest competitor was the UK or Canada.

@Fifths


Anyway, last night I was searching Google Images (not a smart option) for this pic:
http://i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/295/679/618.jpg

I had Safe Search at maximum, in an effort to block R34/porn.
but R34 came up anyway
So does anyone know if it’s just Google or do all search engines fail sometimes in their search censoring? I really don’t like R34/porn coming up in my search results.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 11:05AM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 11:04AM EDT
Quote

@Fifths
Oh, yeah?
Well, last night I had a dream about… well, I don’t remember exactly…
But I do remember that Lyra had a pet goldfish for whatever reason.
… so, yeah.
Screw your stupid ‘indescribable beauty.’
Lyra had a fish!
(Okay, I did an image search on a whim and found this. Now I’m laughing!)

@Popper
That will happen on any search engine. Safe Searches can never be 100% accurate because computers can’t reliably distinguish the content of pictures like a human brain can. Google is probably just using some complex mix of tagging, related sites, search histories, and other info to determine what is and isn’t R34, and that’s always going to be prone to mistakes. Obviously, the more of it that there is, the more likely that one or two will slip through the net.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 11:17AM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 11:15AM EDT
Quote

Ric Tesla wrote:

>That feel when my birthday is September 9th.
I’m going to have some pony to time how long I have before they get me.
But I’ll enjoy every second of it.

>Create Clones of
>Discord

@Fifth’s Dashie B. Goode.

Son-i-am-proud.jpg!

Jun 25, 2012 at 11:23AM EDT
Quote

I have a question for you all…
If there was a one way portal to equestria, and you could only bring one person or thing with you, what/who would you bring? The portal is a 7 feet x 7 feet square, so you can’t bring anything smaller than that (just in case someone answers “my house” because that includes more items in it like your video games, your bed, clothes, etc.)

Jun 25, 2012 at 11:33AM EDT
Quote

I’d stay on this side of the portal. Sure there are ponies on the other side BUT GODDAMN I’D PROBABLY GET EATEN BY A HYDRA BEFORE MEETING ONE!

Jun 25, 2012 at 12:13PM EDT
Quote

@Mega
Hmmm… Most of the things in my house are less than 7′ × 7′ on at least one side…
I would build a 7′ × 7′ × 12734617′ box, jam everything into into it, and slide it through!
HA!
Where’s the fun in hypothetical questions if you can’t cheat?

Jun 25, 2012 at 12:24PM EDT
Quote

I meant a 7 feet x 7 feet x 7 feet box portal
l also meant you can’t bring anything BIGGER than that (it says i cant edit my post after 30 minutes)
Now try again DeadParrot

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 12:47PM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 12:34PM EDT
Quote

@megalolzors
Push everything I want that’s less than 7×7 ahead of me and then jump in last. Once I’m through, rebuild everything at my new living location.

Jun 25, 2012 at 01:20PM EDT
Quote

@Popper
ONLY ONE OBJECT
>implying that you can bring anything you want to equestria

@DeadParrot
You’ve ran from me for the last time scootaloo
I have no choice but to fuse with you
ASSUMING DIRECT CONTROL
Before:

After:

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 01:55PM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 01:53PM EDT
Quote

I’d bring my brother.

As it stands, he’s probably a better defense against manticores, hydras, and other predators than an AK-47 would be, if I know him. So, not only is he my best friend and family, but’s he also a sound tactical advantage against every living thing in Equestria. He also likes ponies.

A lot.

Jun 25, 2012 at 02:20PM EDT
Quote

Was it ever explained why Pinkie just came flying out of the door like that? If not, I propose the explanation be that Pinkie’s Pinkie sense warned her that “if you jump out of the nearest doorway right now, something good will happen.”

Jun 25, 2012 at 02:30PM EDT
Quote

@Megalolzors
I’d bring a Portal gun, but before I go, I’ll shoot a blue portal down on Earth, and then once I’m in Equestria, shoot an orange portal on a wall.
Now I have an infinitely standing Portal that I can use to travel between the two locations. I’ll bring my possessions, and anyone who wants to come, and then close it.


Jun 25, 2012 at 02:33PM EDT
Quote

@Popper:

Portals only work on certain surfaces, if the game was to be believed. The white panels were apparently designed for the sole purpose of carrying portals. I doubt they have similar panels in Equestria, judging by their technology, and you can only bring one object, so you can’t bring a panel yourself.

Jun 25, 2012 at 02:36PM EDT
Quote

Megalolzors wrote:

If there was a one way portal to equestria, and you could only bring one person or thing with you, what/who would you bring?

I would bring a very, very expensive laptop with lots of memory. Before leaving I’d call a meeting with all of the greatest academics on Earth (considering I’d have access to an interdimensional portal with oddly specific luggage rules, I doubt it would be hard to convince people to help me out), and we’d they’d discuss what to download onto it. We’d have to include every great work of literature, accounts of every major historical events, and most importantly, textbook descriptions of all major breakthroughs in science and technology. Also throw in a bunch of games and a shitload of music.

After arriving in Equestria, I’d demand an audience with Princess Celestia (wouldn’t be too hard to get one, since I’d be an alien and all). I would then present to her my magical artefact of ultimate knowledge (i.e. the laptop), and ensure that her best scientists (i.e. Twilight Sparkle) get to work copying and applying the knowledge within. And thus I would lead Equestria on a technological and cultural revolution.

But I hear you ask, “Algernon, you handsome devil, for what reason would you go through all of this effort?”. The answer is simple. The portal is one way, and there’s no way I’m living in Equestria without the internet. I doubt you can fit the internet into a 7’ box, so the next best solution is to have the Equestrians invent it themselves.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 03:04PM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 03:02PM EDT
Quote

CocoaCannon wrote:

I have a question for you all…
If there was a one way portal to equestria, and you could only bring one person or thing with you, what/who would you bring? The portal is a 7 feet x 7 feet square, so you can’t bring anything smaller than that (just in case someone answers “my house” because that includes more items in it like your video games, your bed, clothes, etc.)

hmmm… 7 × 7 feet hmmm?

considering that i don’t own much in the first place (all the clothes i usually wear are in a closet about 5 feet tall and around 2 feet wide, this computer, a laptop, all the video games and misc. CDs/DVDs sitting in a old CM box that came with my PSU, my phone, and some other small stuff that’s just sitting around in my room, and i can simply steal my dad’s .12 gauge shotgun along with some ammo..you know, for those not-so-friendly creatures just in case i end up in the Everfree Forest.)

I can cram them all inside a box big enough to fit through a 7 × 7 foot square portal, push it in there and jump in last, and be on my way. hell, i can probably sell some of the junk i have for some extra bits, and get myself a cheap house in Ponyville… and get a job in the Sugar Cube Corner. (i’m fully capable of baking anyway)

And once i’m settled in, I’d probably ask Twi to come up with a spell to establish an internet connection to earth, and brag via the internet that i’m in Equestria now.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 03:14PM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 03:07PM EDT
Quote

@Fifths
Are you really asking for an explanation of some weird thing that Pinkie did?
It’s Pinkie.
I’m more surprised by her occasional bouts with sanity.

As for your choice of instrument, go with the acoustic guitar. We’ve never seen evidence that Equestria has electric guitar technology (Cutie Mark Crusader song excluded) and you could always steal Octavia’s cello/bass if you wanted to.

@Solaire
Portals can only be sustained on certain surfaces, one of which is anything coated in white gel which just happens to be made of ground-up moon rocks. In a universe with Luna, those would probably be rather easy to get. You’d just need the gun!

@Algernon
If I were to answer seriously (where’s the fun in that?!), I’d say something similar. Computer loaded with info and tech to bring Equestria into the modern age. They seem to have bits and pieces like simple video games, but computers, television, internet, etc. need to happen, too.

Jun 25, 2012 at 03:21PM EDT
Quote

DeadParrot222 wrote:

YOU’LL HAVE TO CATCH ME FIRST!!!

Also:

i left everything i owned in one piece

Jun 25, 2012 at 04:13PM EDT
Quote

UnderWaterTree wrote:

i left everything i owned in one piece

Why would you give everything you own to PIRATES?!?!

Unrelated:

Jun 25, 2012 at 04:30PM EDT
Quote

CocoaCannon wrote:

I have a question for you all…
If there was a one way portal to equestria, and you could only bring one person or thing with you, what/who would you bring? The portal is a 7 feet x 7 feet square, so you can’t bring anything smaller than that (just in case someone answers “my house” because that includes more items in it like your video games, your bed, clothes, etc.)

I wouldn’t go through it, but I would currupt equestria by throwing in guns and ammo, the anarchist cookbook, and a box of drugs and the means of reproducing them. Equestria would then burn.

Jun 25, 2012 at 06:26PM EDT
Quote

CocoaCannon wrote:

I have a question for you all…
If there was a one way portal to equestria, and you could only bring one person or thing with you, what/who would you bring? The portal is a 7 feet x 7 feet square, so you can’t bring anything smaller than that (just in case someone answers “my house” because that includes more items in it like your video games, your bed, clothes, etc.)

I bring with me the continent of North America.

Jun 25, 2012 at 08:28PM EDT
Quote

@Connor

Hey Connor can I update some of my Bio information. Pwetty please? Bolded changed parts:

Thread Occupation: TL;DR and serious discussions, crashing Windows whenever Chrome tries to do anything with Flash
Likes: Programming, Thread Games, Drawing, Overthinking, D&B Music, Crashing Windows
Dislikes: Negativity
Favorite Pony: All of them (but mostly Derpy)
Favorite Episode: Luna Eclipsed (and most of Season 2 really)
Brony Since: Late October 2011
Other Information: Member of the late night debate club and founder of the KYM DNB club. Enjoys reading TL;DR’s and checking out fan-art (sometimes draws own…sometimes). Local HTML wizard.

Jun 25, 2012 at 08:44PM EDT
Quote

I thought of a hilarious new idea for a fanfic. Pirates of The CareBearibbean. It’s Pirates but with Care Bears as villians. And Berry Punch is an even drunker Jack Sparrow. If it exists already, you get one free groin kick.

Jun 25, 2012 at 08:50PM EDT
Quote

Still Erin wrote:

Brony Bios have been updated with a few new users. Remember to send in yours if you want on the list.

cool bios bro
now I need to get back to rustlin

Jun 25, 2012 at 09:09PM EDT
Quote

RandomMan wrote:

I bring with me the continent of North America.

Through a 7×7 foot portal (ಠ_ಠ)?
Well I’m not gonna question your interpretation of physics RandomMan, I guess you could just squeeze it through with a small amount of butter….
@Derpy
Yes, it does rustle my jimmies.
BUT IT DOESN’T SHNIGGY MY DIGGIDYS!



Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 09:13PM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 09:09PM EDT
Quote

Maiden Heaven wrote:

I thought of a hilarious new idea for a fanfic. Pirates of The CareBearibbean. It’s Pirates but with Care Bears as villians. And Berry Punch is an even drunker Jack Sparrow. If it exists already, you get one free groin kick.

Last edited Jun 25, 2012 at 09:22PM EDT
Jun 25, 2012 at 09:21PM EDT
Quote

@Connor

Here’s mine.

Thread Occupation: Posting depressing and overly philosophical tl;dr, posting original pony music in a desperate plea for attention.
Likes: Ponies, music, chess, sex, swearing, and philosophy
Dislikes: Tons of things, but my deepest ire is reserved for pretentiousness, incompetence, weakness of character, and pseudo-philosophy.
Favorite pony: Normally it’s Rainbow Dash, but sometimes it’s Rainbow Dash.
Favorite Episode: Luna Eclipsed comes to mind.
Brony since: July 2011, but I only admitted it to myself in March 2012
Other information: Just three things you need to remember about me: Music, depression, Rainbow Dash.

Jun 25, 2012 at 11:24PM EDT
Quote

Didn’t Connor say to PM him with these?

…Eh, screw it.

Thread Occupation: Parody song writer, soon to be Fanfic writer and AMV/PMV/YTP maker.

Likes: Media, art, Vidya games, anime/manga, comics/cartoons, internet, good fanfics.

Dislikes: Negativity, intolerance of any sort, butthurt of various varieties, Reality TV,
politicians/the government, most people, himself.

Favorite Pony: (Favorite Mane6: Rarity) (Favorite CMC: Sweetie Belle) (Favorite Background(?): Derpy) (Favorite Princess: Luna) (Favorite other: Big Mac)

Favorite Episode: All the two-parters.

Brony Since: …Somewhere around the time Over a barrel premiered. I don’t remember.

Other Information: First degree black belt, Collector of various blades, Dad owns various guns, HUGE Nintendo fanboy, likely to blurt out controversial opinions.

BTW, new pony parody tomorrow, for now I’m busy thinking of a battleplan…

Last edited Jun 26, 2012 at 12:05AM EDT
Jun 26, 2012 at 12:03AM EDT
Quote

Oh, what the hell.
I’m bored.

Thread Occupation: Resident Scoot-obsessed freak. Endlessly plugging ‘Tiny Wings,’ available in my profile! =)

Likes: Video games, fun discussions, and, oh yeah, Scootaloo.

Dislikes: Irrationality, willful ignorance, taking things too seriously, not liking Scootaloo.

Favorite Pony: … ಠ_ಠ

Favorite Episode: Probably Cutie Mark Chronicles, but I’ve never disliked an episode so it’s hard to tell. (This will immediately update to Scootaloo’s episode when she gets one, damn it!)

Brony Since: May 2011, found it right here on KYM.

Other Information: Eagle Scout, BA in Applied Mathematics

Jun 26, 2012 at 12:23AM EDT
Quote

Thread Occupation: Sometimes posts, sometimes doesn’t.
Likes: Ponies, History, Anime, Minecraft.
Dislikes: Call of Duty games, Kids who are naughty and think they’re cool for doing it, Family Guy, Apple.
Favorite Pony: Fluttershy.
Favorite Episode: The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Brony Since: September 2011, watched it because it started getting spammed everywhere.
Other Information: Closet Brony, my family know about it, my friends don’t.

Last edited Jun 26, 2012 at 01:59AM EDT
Jun 26, 2012 at 01:54AM EDT

So, am I the only one mentally unstable enough to do this, or do you guys ever find yourselves talking to the ponies while watching an episode? Normally, I’m happy to just sit there giggling like a little bitch, but sometimes a passion seizes me that I feel compelled to vocalize. I can think of three notable instances.

1: When Dash and Spike were trolling Twilight when she was trying to stand still for a week. I kept repeating “You guys are bad friends, you guys are bad friends.” while wearing a big stupid grin. This was one of those weird instances where Dash does something dickish which I find to be somehow endearing.

2: The mane six were sitting around having a discussion and I felt the need to contribute my two bits. Rarity wouldn’t stop talking however, so I paused the video and told her “shut up, I’m trying to say something” I felt kind of bad about that though, so I curtly apologized and made my point.

3: Fluttershy gave Pinkie and Rarity that Brutal verbal beat down, what I found to be one of the most emotionally powerful moments of the entire series. So as she is trashing Rarity and Pinkie’s special talents, I felt the need to all but yell “Bitch, you run a fucking animal shelter. This episode opened with you getting bitchslapped by a motherfucking rabbit!”

You know, I don’t think Fluttershy ever adequately apologized for that either. That shit was pretty brutal.

Jun 26, 2012 at 02:09AM EDT
Quote

>Midnight
>Checks thread
>4 moar bios in addition to 4 from PMs
>MFW

No sleep for me tonight…
I’m also sorting them alphabetically.

P.S. I really would appreciate any others to be PMs so they don’t clog the thread and so I can find them more easily. Thank you!~

Jun 26, 2012 at 02:24AM EDT
Quote

@Fifths
I can’t remember ever talking directly to the characters, but I do recall a very distinct ‘Did she just say?!’ when Rainbow Dash said Derpy’s name and a whole lot of ‘No freaking way!’s during Derpy’s lines followed by at least five minutes of alternating between stunned silence and ridiculous giggling. As I recall, that was back when the episode synchtubes were broadcasting at 5 a.m. Pacific time and I had stayed up all night to watch it live. My brain was so out of it that, I kid you not, my first thought when Derpy spoke was ‘Did someone slip a fan animation into the livestream?’
It took the rest of the episode for me to accept that that had actually happened, then I watched it at least two of three more times!

@Connor
Suddenly, bronies!
Hundreds (i.e: eight) of them!

Jun 26, 2012 at 02:52AM EDT
Quote

Algernon wrote:

And thus I would lead Equestria on a technological and cultural revolution.

Have fun introducing them to Gunpowder and environmentally destructive Industrial practices!

Jun 26, 2012 at 03:17AM EDT
Quote

@DeadParrot

I remember watching it and even though I was amused by the whole thing, I couldn’t shake the feeling that something bad was going to come of this.

Score one for my psychic powers.

You know, the Last Roundup was a really well done episode, easily in my top 5 favorite. Everything about Pinkie being used to torture Applejack was just priceless, the dialogue, the musical score adding dramatic tension. Then there was the part where Pinkie turned into THE FREAKING DEVIL over the broken Pinkie promise. Hell, they even managed to genuinely intrigue me as to why AJ hadn’t come home for awhile before bringing in the boring old “I didn’t get first prize” thing.

It’s really a shame that everyone only remembers it for the Derpy lines and the later, ugh, alterations.

Jun 26, 2012 at 03:25AM EDT
Quote

Welp, I’ve haven’t posted here for two months or whatever.
Not that I was actually important to the thread, but that ain’t the point I came here for.
I am here to challenge you to find ‘pony’ of something I seriously have never seen ponified. Or even had been suggested to be ponified.
An adorable game called LcDDeM. The ‘character’ in question I would like to see in pony mode is Chie. The ‘protagonist’ if you wish to call her that.
If you do this.
I will shower you in imaginary karma.
It will be beautiful.

Jun 26, 2012 at 03:36AM EDT
Quote

Fifths wrote:

So, am I the only one mentally unstable enough to do this, or do you guys ever find yourselves talking to the ponies while watching an episode? Normally, I’m happy to just sit there giggling like a little bitch, but sometimes a passion seizes me that I feel compelled to vocalize. I can think of three notable instances.

1: When Dash and Spike were trolling Twilight when she was trying to stand still for a week. I kept repeating “You guys are bad friends, you guys are bad friends.” while wearing a big stupid grin. This was one of those weird instances where Dash does something dickish which I find to be somehow endearing.

2: The mane six were sitting around having a discussion and I felt the need to contribute my two bits. Rarity wouldn’t stop talking however, so I paused the video and told her “shut up, I’m trying to say something” I felt kind of bad about that though, so I curtly apologized and made my point.

3: Fluttershy gave Pinkie and Rarity that Brutal verbal beat down, what I found to be one of the most emotionally powerful moments of the entire series. So as she is trashing Rarity and Pinkie’s special talents, I felt the need to all but yell “Bitch, you run a fucking animal shelter. This episode opened with you getting bitchslapped by a motherfucking rabbit!”

You know, I don’t think Fluttershy ever adequately apologized for that either. That shit was pretty brutal.

No, can’t say I ever really did that, but thanks for the hilarious mental scene! Particularly your conversation with Rarity, that’s priceless (and no, I’m not being sarcastic).

However, about number three…

You just don’t understand her pain, you heartless monster.

In all seriousness though, I’m starting to feel like I’m the only one who found Putting Your Hoof Down to be outrageously OOC for Fluttershy. It just makes no sense that a pony who was all “Were we arguing? I’m sorry…” in season one would hand out such a tongue lashing to her closest friends after spending a few hours with Hercule Satan. Discord, I can understand, but this? Yes, I understand that a show like this doesn’t really take it that seriously, but what can I say, good characterization is one of the things I fell in love with in FIM. There’s only one possible explanation.

*Note: I do think her other episodes, namely, The Mysterious Mare Do Well, Hearth’s Warming Eve, and Dragon Quest were all fantastic.


@DeadParrot Below

What in the world are we coming to when all we admire in someone is their flaws? Applejack isn’t perfect by any means; but her many character strengths are precisely why I think she’s awesome. I happen to really like a character that’s stable and sane. Crazy ponies may be good for a gag or ten, but the more reasonable your characters are, the higher the chances are for more complex and deep story-writing, if you ask me.

Last edited Jun 26, 2012 at 04:00AM EDT
Jun 26, 2012 at 03:47AM EDT
Quote

@Fifths
Very true. Don’t forget the awesome I Love Lucy scene in the middle, and the simultaneously exciting and silly chase scene at the end. Lots of great stuff in there, although it does bring up the whole ‘AJ is best background pony’ thing. Even in an obvious AJ episode, everyone remembers Derpy and Pinkie most of all. In my opinion, Rarity said it best in Sisterhooves Social:

Frankly, AJ is just too ‘good’ to be all that interesting, or for me at least. She’s typically the voice of reason and the one most likely to take a step back from the crazy her friends display. While she fills a vital role in the structure of many episodes by doing so, it’s the more apparent flaws that other characters have that make them more appealing and entertaining to watch.

Jun 26, 2012 at 03:50AM EDT
Quote

@Best background pony
Think of it this way: her fatal flaw is that she works too hard. Some of the others, like Pinkie, have self-esteem/multiple personality issues. She’s just too perfect compared to the others, and being too perfect usually makes them a Mary Sue rather than a good character.
I personally think AJ’s perfectly fine, if not underloved and I hope to see more of her in season 3.

Jun 26, 2012 at 04:37AM EDT
Quote
Skeletor-sm

This thread is closed to new posts.

This thread was locked by an administrator.

Why don't you start a new thread instead?

O HAI! You must login or signup first!