Pizza is a Vegetable
Part of a series on Pizza. [View Related Entries]
Overview
"Pizza is a Vegetable" is a satirical expression inspired by a spending bill passed by the U.S. Congress in November 2011, which bars the Department of Agriculture from changing the nutritional guidelines for public school lunches, such as raising the minimum amount of tomato paste on pizza to be counted as a serving of vegetable.
Background
On November 14th, 2011, the Associated Press[15] reported that U.S. House Republicans put forth a spending bill that would bar the USDA from changing its nutritional guidelines for school lunches, which would've required more green vegetables and set a higher qualification for tomato paste to be counted as vegetables from 2 tablespoons to a a half-cup. The article also revealed that part of the spending bill would protect the status of tomato paste on pizza as a vegetable at the request of food companies supplying the nation's school cafeterias.
Legal Precedence
According to Wikipedia[3], tomatoes are botanically considered a fruit since they contain seeds but the United States Supreme Court ruled in the 1893 Nix v. Hedden decision that tomatoes should be considered a vegetable for trade purposes. During this period, taxes were required for all vegetables imports and the Supreme Court ruled against the Nix family's attempt to recover back duties paid to the Collector of the Port of New York.
Spread
On November 16th, a thread titled "Congress declares pizza a vegetable" reached the front page of Reddit[6] and accumulated over 1,200 up votes within a week. The earliest known image macro was posted by Redditor Wings144 the following day, titled "Scumbag Congress…"[7] (shown below).
On November 16th, 2011, TheYoungTurks YouTube channel uploaded a video about the news story, whicih mocked the proposed bill (shown below).
On November 18th, a screenshot of a news article titled "US Congress rules that pizza is a vegetable" with the "I don't want to live on this planet anymore" image macro was posted to the Cheezburger site Memebase[9] (shown below). The same day, a compilation of image macros referencing the news story were posted to the Cheezburger site FAILblog.[12]
On November 20th, a thread featuring pizza-vegetable images was posted on the Body Building Forums.[8] On the following day, the Internet news site UpRoxx[16] published a post titled "Meme Watch: Pizza is Apparently a Vegetable," featuring a slideshow of notable example images. On November 23rd, YouTuber Jonathan Mann uploaded a "Pizza is a Vegatable" music video (show below). Additional examples of the meme have been posted on Tumblr[10], FunnyJunk[11] and Reddit.[13] As of October 4th, 2012, a Facebook[14] page for "When I was your age, pizza wasn't a vegetable" has accumulated 180 likes.
Notable Examples
Many images were created parodying the proposed congressional bill, including photoshopped pizzas on a variety of plants and image macros with captions mocking the classification of pizza as a vegetable.
Search Interest
Search queries for "pizza is a vegetable" climbed dramatically in November of 2011 immediately after the bill was released.
External References
[1] MSNBC via Wayback Machine – Pizza is a vegetable? Congress says yes
[2] Education Week – Is Pizza a Vegetable? In School Lunches, Congress Says Yes
[4] Wikipedia – Nix v. Hedden
[5] Washington Post – Congress did not declare pizza a vegetable
[6] Reddit – Congress declares pizza a vegetable
[7] Reddit – Scumbag Congress…
[8] Body Building Forums – Pizza Vegetable meme is making me lol
[9] Memebase – Pizza Is A Veggie!
[10] Tumblr – pizza is a vegetable
[11] FunnyJunk – pizza is a vegetable (must be logged in)
[12] FAILBlog via Wayback Machine – I Can Actually Hear The School Children Cheering!
[13] Reddit – pizza vegetable
[14] Facebook – When I was your age, pizza wasn't a vegetable
[15] Associated Press via Wayback Machine – Congress pushes back on healthier school lunches
[16] UpRoxx – Meme Watch – Pizza is Apparently a Vegetable
[17] The Huffington Post – How Pizza Became A Vegetable Through The Magic Of Influence-Peddling
.jpg "Pizza Crimes"){kind=icon}
Top Comments
Suiseiseki
Nov 18, 2011 at 09:08PM EST
Blue Screen (of Death)
Nov 18, 2011 at 11:08PM EST